logoalt Hacker News

Stop Filming in Log?

69 points • by dabinat • yesterday at 4:37 AM • 75 comments • view on HN

Comments

Spiwux • yesterday at 6:14 AM

I don't understand this post. It doesn't explain the concrete problems with grading log footage. And you can convert log footage to REC709 in a way that would give you the same result as if you'd just recorded in REC709 to begin with. At least for most established camera brands. Maybe this post is referring to grading more fringe brands that have bad/undocumented color science or don't offer proper conversion paths?

Either way it does not explain the concrete issues of recording in log. If you have a strong title like "Stop doing X" you better have some damn good arguments if you think you can tell other people what to do.

➕ show 5 replies
dubbie99 • yesterday at 10:29 AM

As a vfx supervisor with strong color science knowledge (I have designed the color pipeline for more than one studio) and written many specs for the color workflow on feature films… this is a very frustrating thread to read. A major problem with color science is that the terms are poorly defined, many are overloaded, and half the challenge of having a constructive conversation is to be sure you are all speaking the same language. There aren’t many people who understand digital color well, so the majority of info on the web is wrong or confusing. You have the spend a long time to get to the point where color no longer has any mystery to you.

Having said all that. Shoot log always. But if you are viewing log on set while you are shooting and composing your picture, you are doing it horribly wrong. You need to choose a viewing lut and look at your pictures through that.

➕ show 1 reply
lambdaone • yesterday at 8:02 AM

The author is being intentionally provocative, as they admit in their first sentence. I can see what they are trying to get at, which is that film-makers should not abuse HDR and set their exposure intentionally for viewer comfort, rather than trying to fix everything in post, but shooting Rec. 709, an old colour standard with wonky primaries derived from old-fashioned CRT TV phosphors, seems like a really peculiar way of going about it. "Make it look like DVD" should not be the ideal of film-making.

➕ show 1 reply
buildbot • yesterday at 5:46 AM

Color science/color management seems like a complete dark art; super interesting post. The rest of the blog is full of cool posts about film production in general.

For example, https://digitalfilms.wordpress.com/2025/08/15/the-film-look-...

➕ show 3 replies
bede • yesterday at 9:59 AM

Presumably this choice should be dictated more than anything by the capture device. ARRI colour discussed in the article is famously good / critically acclaimed, and a great starting point as suggested. For many cameras however—especially lower end pro and consumer gear—shooting log is the best escape from an awfully oversaturated default colour profile.

rob74 • yesterday at 9:57 AM

TIL that "log" has more meanings than (1) a piece of wood or (2) some sort of periodic data recording, be it a ship's log or a server log. In this case it's short for "logarithmic profile" (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Log_profile).

wyager • yesterday at 5:44 AM

The point of shooting in a log format isn't to make the footage look a certain way; it's to reduce the degree to which quantization/clipping throws away information you want to have in post.

If you film with a standardized transfer function like HLG or S-Log3, you should be able to apply the inverse OETF in your grading software and work in whatever color space you want (linear, ACEScct, etc.). If you want, you can just compress to rec.709 there! There's really no need to squash to rec.709 in the camera.

➕ show 1 reply
loki-ai • yesterday at 6:46 AM

ironically the post shows how tricky color management can be, where him gets multiple facts wrong. just go after some proper technical literature, ignore youtube influencers on the topic and continue shooting in log

zuInnp • yesterday at 6:16 AM

The whole “how to take a video” bubble in the internet is rather confusing. You find so many hints and tutorials and advice about how to shoot and color correct … it is pretty confusing. Last year I learned about the correct position of the log to rec 709 transformation, which makes sense looking now at it, but which also means I did it wrong for some years

➕ show 1 reply
KaiserPro • yesterday at 9:24 AM

Strap in children, you're about to get a stream of consciousness from someone who was there in the old days.

Unless I have missed something re.709 is 8bit. rec 7.09 is the colourspace that most "full HD" screens can sorta reproduce in an "accurate" way (spoiler, most of them dont, but thats another issue. )

The author talks about cineon which is/was a 10 bit log format meant to record film "properly". From what I remember, and how it was explained to me was: we want the detail in the blacks, because thats where we are keen to make changes. I never was involved in actual film processing so I don't know what the frequency response of film is, all I know was that for the longest time it had greater dynamic range than digital(depending on the stock you were using).

Now what the author misses out in the talk about RED cameras is that actually their colour was a bit dodgy. Mind you, so were a lot of the other cameras at the time. (a lot of people were filming on canon 5dmk3, and then a whole range of other weird cameras)

With film, you'd send it to a DI lab to get scanned. You'd sit with the colourist, who's team would have conformed the base grade to something normal, and then the colourist would do magic according to what you wanted (assuming you had enough headroom)

For film, you'd ever print out to film again, so keep that 10/12bit colour, or dump out to DCP, which was, I seem to recall jpeg2000 (much like RED....)

Now for most of us, we don;t have that kind of cash, which, I suppose is the point of the article.

So, advice:

1) don't shoot with RED. They are bastard cameras, some of them are colourblind (see the hobbit)

2) turn zebras on in your camera (they give you a visual warning of over/under exposed areas in your shot)

3) use the live histogram. If you have massive peaks somewhere, you need to adjust.

4) light properly. film looks like film, mostly because of the lighting allowing you to grade the way you do.

5) shoot a macbeth chart in your scene, that way you can use the auto tools to make a base grade.

there is nothing wrong with log. Out of the camera it looks flat and a bit grey. find the macbeth chart, use the tooling to capture the output and set a base grade. Then drag a LUT in to make it look the way it should (there are loads of premade LUTs now, so go and grab a few and try them out. )

Digital cameras are wonderful, and with a bit of skill allow you to shoot sumptuous looking stuff without an entire team of set and in post. Log is fine, its a reasonable way to store the 14+ bits of colour that mp4/h265 cant really render. just make sure you have davinci or what ever adobe has set up to receive and correct the colour

➕ show 1 reply
klodolph • yesterday at 5:52 AM

Yeah. I’m not really a professional here but I would say sensitometry is something of an interest of mine. Take what I’m saying with the appropriate grain of salt.

Your camera has some sensor which records some range of values. The range is a lot wider than your monitor can reproduce and generally follows some curve up to a maximum value, where the highlights clip.

Log is something of a fantasy in that it represents an idealized, mathematical idea of what your camera does, but it does not really correspond to what the sensor does or what the monitor displays. You can convert your video to log, or from log, but the log data itself is only really useful as an intermediate step when post-processing. I don’t think you need to capture in log. I would just go for some “regular” wide like Canon’s Wide DR.

YMMV, I am a little old-school about these things and there is a lot of stuff that I prefer to do in-camera. (Be warned that while doing things in post gives you flexibility to undo your work and change your mind, there are a lot of things you can’t reasonably do in post… even things that seem basic like white balance are better to do with lighting or filters, and if you don’t understand the sensitometry then you can easily end up with footage that you can’t rescue in post.)

➕ show 3 replies
LoganDark • yesterday at 7:41 AM

The crux of the article appears to be that it's too much effort. If you enjoy the effort, like me, nothing has changed.

jiggawatts • yesterday at 8:02 AM

> Understand that HDR video is not the same thing as HDR photography. They use different science and apply different technology to the sensor image.

This is where the author lost all credibility.

I have a Nikon Z8 "hybrid" camera that can take breathtaking 4K HDR footage or HDR still images.

I can easily develop both the stills and video from the same sensor, the same lenses, and interleave them in the same HDR video and have the two be nigh indistinguishable. It just looks like pressing the "pause button" on the video.

The differences -- if any -- are largely down to historical or stylistic choices, and can be freely changed depending on one's preference.

At the end of the day, they're just... lookup tables.

➕ show 3 replies