logoalt Hacker News

stonedivot • today at 3:32 PM • 3 replies • view on HN

I highly doubt that, these days, those are the kinds of experts visiting this website. And if they are, there's very little left of the hacker mindset. This is basically Reddit-lite.


Replies

IAmGraydon • today at 5:25 PM

The hackers are still here, but the population of the low-quality posters has grown much larger than it used to be, so the signal to noise ratio is low. You see a lot of replies now where people are just trying to make the most idiotic/formulatic joke possible for upvotes. That is definitely something you see at Reddit and something you never used to see here until recently. I really wish DanG would have implemented some kind of vote-to-ban mechanism before it got this out of control as it's clearly impossible for him to police by himself.

Dove • today at 5:24 PM

I had the same thought. I came here expecting incisive analysis, and while I found some pretty far down the page, I found a mix of dismissive and curious confusion in all the top comments. The top comment can't figure out "Faviconese" or follow a witty commentary on the danger of clicking strange links. Really? Confusion about creative expression? As the top comment? "Oh right," I thought, "it's 2026. I guess that's how far things have fallen."

And then it hit me that I've been coming to this web site for seventeen years and that things change over time.

And I'll admit, society as a whole seems to have taken a turn for the worse in this department. There was a time when merely being online was something of a filter, and knowing about HN definitely was. Alas, walls being free is a special case. They usually have to be built. In the absence of catechesis, creed, peer review, editorial board, secret handshake, something, the masses draw a culture to the mean.

Edit: In the hour since I last looked, the intelligent crowd I expected seems to be showing up in force. Perhaps it was a fluke. I'll put away my doomsday sign about how the robots and the zombies are coming. They are, though.

caust1c • today at 3:52 PM

Nonsense, theres literally dozens of us still here! XD