logoalt Hacker News

simonh • today at 3:46 PM • 4 replies • view on HN

To be fair to the institution, prior to March 2026 it was quite reasonable not to expect an imminent full scale air war with Iran with no warning.

The US military doesn't get to decide for itself what conflicts it is or isn't going to get into, and must be prepared for. If the politicians suddenly decide to start a conflict, it's on them to make sure the military is capable of it.


Replies

flossly • today at 4:18 PM

If you do this in feb'26:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2026_Minab_school_attack

You can expect anything by march'26.

The US can do some regime change operation, or topple some banana republic's govt; but they cannot win a real war. Not in Vietnam, not in Ukraine, not in Iran, not in Korea. The US controlled Afghanistan to some extend, only to give control back to the Talibs they took it from. Japan capitulated to the west at the end of ww2, not because of the a-bombs, but because they preferred to capitulate to the west over losing a war with the Soviets/China (they were hated by the Chinese following several large scale massacres). Arguably the US/west/allies did not win in Europe during ww2 (the Soviets were responsible for most of Germany's losses, and D-day was started when a Soviet win was imminent).

The US' hegemony is largely a PR campaign. Their military industry is so expensive (relatively high production cost and too much money for the middle men) that they cannot out produce even Russia.

➕ show 1 reply
rurp • today at 4:00 PM

This really shows how utterly incompetent the current administration is. The Iran war was a complete war of choice with no urgency. In a sane administration basic preparations would have been in place months before launching a major conflict. Instead they bumbled into a quagmire and got caught off guard by retaliation (Hormuz, drones, etc) so obvious that most inexperienced students would have seen coming.

➕ show 2 replies
rayiner • today at 4:18 PM

> To be fair to the institution, prior to March 2026 it was quite reasonable not to expect an imminent full scale air war with Iran with no warning.

The military has had plans to attack Iran since the 1980s. Trump waving around a classified plan to attack Iran in 2021 was one of the key facts in the classified documents prosecution.

➕ show 1 reply
Waterluvian • today at 3:48 PM

This feels like the "we're all trying to find the guy who did this" meme.