logoalt Hacker News

voakbasda • today at 3:57 PM • 2 replies • view on HN

Are you really sure about your facts?

I am getting really tired of seeing people shitting on other people’s hard work for no reason other than it was written by AI.

Software has always been sloppy. There are plenty of UI written by humans that look like shit, even after spending more money than likely was burned here.

If you think this effort is so bad, then show us how you could do better without AI. Otherwise, your kind of snark is not contributing constructively here (or anywhere).


Replies

fock • today at 4:29 PM

well, this goes into the area, where bugs can make your workshop go up in flames (or your devices doing nothing). Kind of weird to use vibecoding for that, but ok...

pona-a • today at 5:17 PM

> people’s hard work

> written by AI

I'm getting tired of people shitting on other people's work just because someone else did everything for them!

> Software has always been sloppy

Whatever your opinion on AI is, can we at least agree if you can tell from one look it's slop, you must have been holding it wrong?

People make mistakes, and they learn from them. This is at best training a rented SaaS, while the operator is paying for the privilege.

> show us how you could do better without AI

Believe me or not, I also have some projects in electronics, and I do disclose my AI usage, or often lack thereof. I don't happen to own a Rigol scope, and honestly don't have the skills or interest to reverse engineer my own scope.

I could probably contribute a better UI, but let's be honest, is the author interested in that contribution? Probably not.

Will anyone in good faith argue you can't levy any criticism, unless you first make a competing product? This is not even forbidding customers from criticizing a restaurant, this is you also excluding fellow chefs, just because they won't cook the same meal for you on the spot.