logoalt Hacker News

thisislife2 • today at 4:46 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

It isn't as simple as that - most Westerners have this idea that the Iran government is a repressive regime run by a dictator. But it is actually a hybrid democratic-authoritarian-theocratic system by design. This system allowed the Iranian people to exercise some choice on who governs them. Thus, many Iranians also admired and supported it as they see it something very "Iranian", unique and specific to their culture. (Remember that Iranians, unlike the individualistic West, are a collective / cooperative society, and thus some authoritarianism is part of their culture). Indeed, talk with any foreign diplomat or politicians, and they will tell you that among the Islamic states in the middle-east, Iran is the most democratic one. Western experts on the middle-east (and even Israeli ones) are well aware of this. And so they knew that the most desirable outcome of killing the current ruler was that it trigger a civil war (remember that the Ayatollah was also a religious leader, and has a great following amongst Shia Muslims around the world). A civil war would give them an excuse to send the troops to Iran, and divide their country by occupying parts of it, while Iranians themselves would provide the cannon-fodder for the whole conflict. Americans would also be more likely to support this. It would have allowed the invaders to chip away any resistance and slowly occupy the whole country. (Remember, the ultimate goal was always colonialism and resource grab. And of course, for the Israeli religious fundamentalists, their dream of annexing Iranian territory to forge the "Greater Israel").

Sure, the authoritarians remain in power with brute force. But we would be lying to ourselves if we don't acknowledge that there is still a substantial support for their current form of governance in the population.

An economic blockade, or attempts to starve them is again, something foolish, as it will only strengthen the hands of the religious leaders in Iran - martyrdom is a core part of Shia Islam and Iranian culture. (But sadly, yes, it may yet allow the Americans to subjugate and colonise the Iranians in time, if they are willing to overlook the war crimes and Iranian human cost of doing so, which is quite likely - the Iranians shouldn't forget that they are fighting a superpower who is quite comfortable with genocide. In such a case, it may actually be a better strategy, in the long-term to let them occupy you and then fight them).


Replies

torginus • today at 5:28 PM

I think it's some sort of Western blindness, to take something obviously sanctimonious and take it at face value. I'm sure many (most?) Christian kings of the European middle ages have claimed that their rule was necessary to worship the one true Christian god correctly, and not even the most devout Christians of today would buy this argument, and wouldn't really link their religion and feudalism together.

It's the same with Iranians and muslims in general - some power hungry people are using religion to usurp and hold on to power. Like the Christian kings of old, some of these people might be competent and otherwise benevolent, but I don't think either the common folk or the leadership of Iran is different to the rest of us.