logoalt Hacker News

sosodev • yesterday at 7:28 PM • 8 replies • view on HN

Because there’s not one, shared cause between the outages. The lay person claims it must be AI, but that’s a bit meaningless.


Replies

bobson381 • yesterday at 7:33 PM

The reason I say not entirely, is because there is kind of a shared cause. One way of looking at is is that the root cause is complexity, optimized for efficiency and speed rather than robustness. It's a feature of the economic superorganism we are operating as part of. See Joseph Tainter on Collapse of Complex Societies, the work of Nate Hagens, Schmachtenberger & Liv Boree talking about Moloch, etc.

➕ show 2 replies
foo12bar • yesterday at 9:23 PM

Maybe we're not looking far enough up the chain. Everyone used to use forums and other websites run by other people (eg Substack) to read and discuss about things they don't understand.

Now when people have a question, they ask AI, which is wrong a lot of the time.

vintermann • yesterday at 7:41 PM

What does the "pro" person claim? That it's Iran?

➕ show 4 replies
Waterluvian • yesterday at 7:40 PM

Imagine a tree of relationships branching up to the very top labelled, "Because the Universe Exists" as being the root issue that relates everything.

Saying it's not related applies an assumption of what level of specificity you are thinking about. And that's how you quickly de-sync with other people, especially "lay people" who look at you funny when you claim there's just no way these things are related when it's hard to believe that based on experience alone.

As other comments suggest, it probably is related to an extent. Related by complexity of our Internet-based systems, related by age, related maybe even by enshittification of expertise, etc.

The further up the tree you find these relationships, the less specifically actionable they are (you cannot CVE enshittification), and the more they are about "what are the overall social/cultural/human issues we're grappling with in this era?"

➕ show 1 reply
PhunkyPhil • yesterday at 7:30 PM

To be fair, have there been post-mortems for any of them? Besides vague tweets or press statements?

➕ show 1 reply
Muromec • yesterday at 7:42 PM

> The lay person claims it must be AI, but that’s a bit meaningless.

Must be the water then

cyberax • yesterday at 7:39 PM

Is there?

Apparently the FAA outage was caused by the pressure to do things quickly, fueled by the AI urgency.

It feels like all the IT industry is feeling this pressure.

aaroninsf • yesterday at 7:41 PM

a) this is not known, there is no reliable data on either the FAA or new bank issue; and the information forthcoming from Microsoft may obscure primary causation

b) there is also a risk of sophistry and language games obscuring common sense truth

In the world where a state actor is engaging in active sabotage as part of a cyberwarfare effort, there is one shared cause.

Which exploits are responsible in each case may differ. Still one cause.

Do I think it's Iran?

No idea.

But the point is, none of us here have any idea at present.