logoalt Hacker News

xg15 • yesterday at 8:01 PM • 9 replies • view on HN

Can someone explain the difference to me between a rounded rectangle and a squircle?


Replies

layer8 • yesterday at 8:14 PM

The sides of a squircle never become completely straight, they are curved at every point.

One consequence of that is that they scale more nicely for nesting: https://thatsmaths.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/squircles-... (right half of the image)

Of course, Apple’s squircles deviate from that by inserting straight line segments. What remains is that the corners still have a non-constant curvature.

Sharlin • yesterday at 10:39 PM

A highway or railway curve between two straight segments is usually not a simple circle arc. If it were, the sudden discontinuity in higher derivatives (acceleration and jerk) at the transition point from straight to curved would feel uncomfortable, be harder to anticipate and slow down appropriately by a driver, and cause unwanted shear stresses to mechanical parts. So transition curves are used that smoothly vary the curvature from zero to that of the circular segment and back to zero again. The typical transition curve in engineering is called a clothoid, which is one of the squircle types mentioned in the article.

In digital graphic design curvature discontinuities don’t usually cause mechanical issues, but discontinuities in curved shapes can still look jarring – for whatever reason the visual system is rather good at detecting such sudden changes in shapes, even those that naively "should" look smooth.

alanbernstein • yesterday at 9:04 PM

On a rounded rectangle, the shape of the corner is continuous, but the curvature is not - it jumps from 0 to R. Rounded rectangles look fine, but if you're attuned to it, this subtle discontinuity can look just a little bit off.

A squircle is one (actually several variations) approach to making the curvature continuous.

I would say it's still a subjective aesthetic difference, but you can use math jargon to explain why you like one better than the other.

YuechenLi • yesterday at 9:09 PM

A regular rounded rectangle is G1 continuous while a squircle (superellipse) is G2 continuous, which means that it is not only continuous on position and tangent for its outline, but the curvature rate of change for the outline is also continuous, so it's smoother and doesn't have hard difference between "line" and "rounded corner" on the shape.

flowerlad • yesterday at 8:06 PM

A standard rounded rectangle has quarter-circle corners. A squircle starts curving earlier and more gently, with a gradual transition from its flatter sides into its corners.

Personally, I prefer regular old round rectangles. Squircles are ugly.

prideout • yesterday at 9:42 PM

Like Raph's post says: squircles do not have a single agreed-upon mathematical definition. I don't think "rounded rectangle" does either.

➕ show 1 reply
wolttam • yesterday at 8:06 PM

Rounded rectangle is a rectangle with fixed radius corners, a “squircle” is some shape where the corner’s radius is not constant.

(My interpretation)