logoalt Hacker News

torginus • yesterday at 9:59 PM • 2 replies • view on HN

CSAM stands for Child Sexual Abuse Material. Using diffusion models to create naked pics is by any reasonable definition not CSAM since no child is being abused. It's baffling to me that I have to state this, since it's tautological. The reason why child pornography is treated like a horrific crime by all of society, is because it harms actual children - this used to be the actual legal criteria for it.. Extending the reach of the crime to something that has none of that impact seems like a transparent power grab.

Just to counter any obvious moralizing, I am not saying using models like that is okay, but it's an entirely different kind of crime.


Replies

abalashov • yesterday at 10:12 PM

Well, the argument has been that it's a kind of vaguely cosmological or conceptual abuse of children, through the normalisation of sexualised depictions of children and so forth. In the production of such material, children suffer as a class.

The problem is, this viewpoint is infinitely flexible, infinitely elastic and can do a lot of gymnastics. I'm not sure it's compatible with the very concrete and procedural orientation of Anglo-American jurisprudence, particularly.

➕ show 1 reply
nonethewiser • yesterday at 10:29 PM

>The real question, whether indulging sexual desire for children is wrong even when no child is touched

Only if you think right/wrong sex is a function of consent and harm. Which is a very modern idea. And also cant condemn incest between consenting adults.

I see your perspective. It's a very coherent path to normalized ai generated child porn.

➕ show 2 replies