logoalt Hacker News

4star3star • yesterday at 10:16 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

But wait, why is the bar different for this subject matter than for other depictions of immoral acts?

Creating a real video of a real person getting their head chopped off: someone got killed, so that's clearly a problem. Creating a fake video depicting the same decapitation in graphic realism: no one bats an eye - go eat popcorn while it happens on a big screen and laugh about it.

So, why is one violent, illegal depiction given a green light, but another is reasoned about completely differently? I think there may be an argument, there, which is why I'm asking, but it doesn't spring to mind. How would you explain the contradiction to a peaceful alien species who uses asexual reproduction (knows nothing about sex) and is shocked and horrified by the violence that passes as entertainment to us?


Replies

paulryanrogers • yesterday at 11:00 PM

> Creating a fake video depicting the same decapitation in graphic realism: no one bats an eye - go eat popcorn while it happens on a big screen and laugh about it.

I don't think the fake is legal if depicting the same act. One could be at least liable in a civil context.