logoalt Hacker News

martinald • today at 12:14 AM • 0 replies • view on HN

Well firstly, DOCSIS is becoming an increasingly niche technology, and niche technology in telecoms means expensive. There are probably 10,000x more (XGS)G-PON CPEs being manufactured than DOCSIS4.0 ones. I assume similar scale for PON headend equipment.

Secondly, PON basically has no powered equipment outside the 'exchange', which can serve 30k+ customers. DOCSIS requires loads of powered equipment, amplifiers, CMTS etc. This then costs money to power (and in high temps, cool) and more importantly breaks down more often. DOCSIS4.0 requires a lot of upgrades to the 'last mile' part so most telcos have decided to just go the whole way and replace with PON instead of doing all that work and getting none of the operational cost savings.

The issue is the faster you push DOCSIS the more it shows up any problems in your last mile setup.