logoalt Hacker News

fractorial • today at 3:35 AM • 2 replies • view on HN

As much as I wanted to say you’re wrong, you’re right. After reading TFA, the security boundary is not sound.

Wanting agents to act like you is wrong. You need to own that trust boundary. Build whatever tooling satisfies the contract that agents should have a “not”+<you> (or <you>+”-agent”) identity, and you actuate across that boundary explicitly.

For example, I have a second agent GitHub account that points at my human one. That allows me to write a trusted proxy that ACLs its identity tightly.

It cannot write to public repos ever. In the worst possible case, it externalizes to a private repo’s issue tracker. (Still has never happened in ~4 months)

Once you have this, you can let agents run free. But, it isn’t trivial to set up. Moreover, people don’t want to “do the work.”

All this assumes you abide by “never run untrusted agents on trusted hardware.”


Replies

thayne • today at 5:04 AM

I would certainly prefer having separate credentials with permissions limited to what I want to allow the agent to do. However I have run into two problems with that.

The first, and bigger, issue is that some services either don't have have suffiently fine control over permissions, so in order to grant permission to do useful things, I also have to allow it to do dangerous things, or I don't have a way to create a more limited access token at all. I wish that it was more common to allow creating short-lived, limited accces personal access tokens for services.

The smaller issue is that sometimes I do want the agent to do something more risky with my approval, and provide me with sufficient context to make an informed decision. That can sort of be worked around though by telling it to just give me the command to run, then I can audit and run it myself.

➕ show 4 replies
ozim • today at 6:49 AM

There is value in being meat proxy if that proxy enforces quality and security.

Downside is a lot of people would act as pass through meat proxy doing busy work that agents could handle.

So there is quite a lot of nuance here to be handled.