logoalt Hacker News

Brian_K_White • today at 8:19 AM • 0 replies • view on HN

When I was a kid I had a job with a plumber & general contractor. We were sitting behind the van having morning coffee & hard roll before starting one day and there was a new plastic paint bucket on the ground with an aluminum ring fit inside it that held a few tools. It was kind of neat how it was just a simple single part punched out of a single flat sheet and made use of a common 5 gallon paint bucket and togethr it made something kinda sorta useful.

He said it cost about $20 (in like 1992 dollars) and I was gobsmacked and insensed, flabbergasted. Whatva scam, $20 just for that? It's just a standard paint bucket and a single flat punched part, not even stamped into a 3d shape just a flat sheet part!

The owner was not bothered at all and I didn't understand why not. He asked me what I thought it should cost.

Obviously when you start to add up all the things that go into even something as dirt simple as that, it adds up fast and you have a hard time getting it down to $100 by the time it's sitting on a shelf at home depot.

We're both right. If that thing was popular enough to take advantage of real mass production, then sure, it could be very cheap, because the buckets are already mass produced because they are used for many things (minus custom labelling), and the ring could be rolling off a punch by the hundreds per minute. But anything short of real mass production and there are just a lot of people who each need a dollar from each unit. If the object was worth $20 for him in usefulness, or he couldn't make one for $20, then it's worth it. It would probably cost more than that to tell me to make one as his employee, and we had the tools and means to fabricate something like that, and I'm good at stuff like that. The engineer asessment of the value is both true and not.

But it sure is easy to only see one tiny slice of a whole picture.