logoalt Hacker News

robviren • today at 12:15 PM • 2 replies • view on HN

I just remember hearing on NPR how frustrated a parent was that a young student came home with this polished, way too well organized, and clearly AI slopped presentation from school at a young age. She was so frustrated because the point of them doing the task was not to have a presentation, it was to create one with intention. An overly clean thoughtless output does nothing for anyone.

Just waiting for the shoe to drop of course. They'll probably look at it like spell check.


Replies

ben_w • today at 1:05 PM

> Just waiting for the shoe to drop of course. They'll probably look at it like spell check.

Perhaps.

My hope would be that any "cultural enrichment" part of the curriculum is forced to pay attention to what is good rather than merely what our ancestors lionised.

Neither soap operas nor the more acclaimed of Shakespeare's plays appeal to me personally, but the former does actually connect with people and tell stories that resonate today, while Romeo and Juliet and The Merchant of Venice are at this point 33% "why are those kids allowed to do this?", 33% "why haven't they just sent a DM?", and 33% people sharing videos of lawyers discussing how illegal everything is.

Poetry, too. "Dulce et Decorum Est" doesn't connect to people who have no way to imagine either conscription or the recent horror of chemical warfare in trenches. I can, and indeed have, asked ChatGPT:

  Can you re-imagine "Dulce et Decorum Est" as if it were about drone warfare in Donbas?
I won't bore anyone with what the AI gave me, it was derivative rather than imaginative, the kind of thing any of my class might have written 26 years ago when the school had us study Dulce et Decorum Est and discuss the language and imagery it used.
cowlevel • today at 12:49 PM

The school is just teaching the child life skills. Slopping PowerPoints all day to get paid will be the thing we all do in 2040.

➕ show 1 reply