logoalt Hacker News

tootie • today at 2:53 PM • 5 replies • view on HN

It still just strikes me as moral panic. The data are so weak and there's no obvious cause and effect. It's amazing to me how universal the praise is for phone bans even on HN. I really, really do not see the massive harms people are imagining. I also think there are much bigger and far worse causes of kids losing enthusiasm for school and it's the national/global malaise caused by corrupt government, poor outlook for young workers and the looming climate disaster. Focusing on phones is a very misguided attempt to prevent them from knowing about it.


Replies

horsawlarway • today at 3:04 PM

Nah, I'm a parent of 3 kids - it's incredibly noticeable that there's a distinct difference in behavior with electronics vs without.

Are there other problems? Sure.

But this one is obvious, impactful, and easy to fix.

Next - I want to take away the chromebooks and "online" testing that the schools do too, and I'd like to consider a complete blanket ban on any sort of required account/web access for school work. This is near universally a product pushed on teachers by admins who get sold on products by for-profit tech companies.

It's not good for kids, it's good for bottom lines. Rip those fucking things out. Computer access can be a "sit down" at a desktop computer in a computer lab once or twice a week.

karahime • today at 3:02 PM

I think it amounts to focusing on something that seems achievable. The big drivers of problems today are massive, interrelated, and even when they have clear causes, they often lack clear levers to do anything about them. If you take the opioid crisis as an example, there are a million ideas on what the "how" is if one wants to address it, and most of those have the possibility of making the problem worse (e.g. via the iron law of prohibition, where enforcement encourages smugglers to concentrate products to even higher potencies). On the other hand, "tell schools to take phones away from students" is mostly concrete, and allows one to imagine a return of the world to the state it was in during their own childhood.

davidmurdoch • today at 3:00 PM

> national/global malaise caused by corrupt government, poor outlook for young workers and the looming climate disaster

All of these are decades+ old problems.

Phones have trillions of dollars of R&D invested into the best ways to steal attention. But you think that doesn't have any effect on children's ability to learn?

thibsrn • today at 3:05 PM

You are commenting on an article that mentions a scientific national study, saying those harms are imaginary while the study precisely brings up evidence that they are not. This seems illogical to be honest. I am not implying that it's black or white and that this proves anything substantial, but it still contributes to our understanding of the matter.

How much Apple and Samsung stock do you own ?