logoalt Hacker News

threethirtytwo • today at 2:57 PM • 3 replies • view on HN

Tons of people hate university education and call the whole thing useless. I agree with this notion slightly in the sense that you can actually learn all this shit yourself for free. That is not to say university education is completely useless though.

What I hate about this comment is how it’s redirecting AI to promote their political desire to end university education.

Bro. AI is bigger than that. We will soon need to examine the value of education itself.


Replies

glitchc • today at 3:08 PM

Most people don't learn anything on their own. Without incentives, the vast majority of the population would be terrible at reading, writing and math. Without those core skills, other subjects become largely inaccessible.

mjr00 • today at 3:02 PM

> Bro. AI is bigger than that. We will soon need to examine the value of education itself.

What is the implication here, that because of AI people no longer need to be educated?

➕ show 2 replies
vel0city • today at 3:10 PM

> I agree with this notion slightly in the sense that you can actually learn all this shit yourself for free.

I both 100% agree with this in theory and 90% disagree with this in practice. Its like saying you can go become a pro athlete without ever having a single coach in your life. Sure, its possible. Lots of drills and workouts are all written down, just go do them. But having a well-skilled coach who is able to direct you, keep you on task, point out things you're missing, and more is incredibly valuable. In that same vein good educators are your educational coaches. There are tons of topics I would have never chosen to go down, have my original assumptions challenged, and more by having good educators in my life. Both in traditional school and elsewhere.

For sure, once you cross the hurdle of knowing how to read then its all there, just go read the book. The challenging part is having people build you up, point you to the next attainable challenge, and help you when you're struggling.