logoalt Hacker News

sbarre • today at 5:49 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

I tried EGM on a few things over the last couple of weeks.

The biggest pitall, which is called out in the docs, is that the goldfish reviewers are never fully satisfied.

The reviewers will always find something, so you need to be able to recognize when the agent is bikeshedding and that it's time to move on.

Otherwise it's a pretty decent approach, and while I don't think it's anywhere near hands-off, it produced decent specs in both cases that didn't require too much additional hand-tuning before I started implementation.


Replies

Rebelgecko • today at 6:59 PM

I actually prefer how EGM is more hands on. I find that it gives much better designs and outcomes than yolo oneshotting. It's a good balance between vibe coding vs actually being thoughtful and intentional