logoalt Hacker News

billypilgrim • today at 5:54 PM • 9 replies • view on HN

I have yet to find an application for Astra vs Sol where the former is noticeable better. Genuinely asking, does anyone feel a big difference in their work between the two? If so, what are you working on?


Replies

whimsicalism • today at 5:57 PM

Subagent coordination, Astra also performs better on Opus/Fable thinking/modeling shape problems imo, also computer use/thinking about shapes. Astra is able to hear waveform images which is pretty nuts.

For just doing things or coding things up, Sol all the way.

5555watch • today at 7:32 PM

Yes, Astra Ultra is just less friction. I task it and when it finishes it's done.

Once I had very little usage left, so switched to Sol (5.6, 6.1), and also tried asking it to delegate to Luna subagents to save credits. It delivered objectively less quality work and needed much more steering. Such that I eventually gave up on them and just default to Astra for everything. I just occasionally ask it to minimize certain testing and it's good.

zeroxfe • today at 6:01 PM

Wow, that's the opposite of what I see. I always simply use Astra (high), despite the cost and latency overhead -- it's just a lot more reliable. I find that on average it uses fewer tokens for a task (and I lose less hair per task), simply because I don't have to steer it as precisely .

itvision • today at 6:07 PM

I have a 1.5 MB C++ codebase, and at least a third of the tasks that Sol completed required cleaning up by Astra.

Astra usually produced good output from the outset. Sol did not. Astra also designs things more effectively.

chaos_emergent • today at 5:56 PM

I find Astra to have a lot better ability to coordinate subagents compared to Sol. I haven’t found a distinction in the complexity of work they can handle.

➕ show 1 reply
gunalx • today at 5:58 PM

EE/circuit design is way better with astra.

Marha01 • today at 6:15 PM

For creative writing, Astra is better than Sol. Bigger models tend to be better than smaller ones for such tasks.

➕ show 1 reply
zf00002 • today at 6:18 PM

astra makes slightly better small 3d models than sol for me.

vessenes • today at 6:09 PM

Audit