logoalt Hacker News

charcircuit • today at 8:05 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

The proposed chip is already 2 years out of date and lacks many security features that are common place and expected for modern devices. And don't forget how poorly the first campaign for the Librem 5 went where they went radio silent for years and refused to process refunds.


Replies

Jach • today at 9:26 PM

Yeah, feels like no lessons were learned. I actually own an L5 from the first time around -- it was similarly out of date at the time of announcement. I was using an already old Note 3 at the time, and remember thinking that the proposed specs were fairly comparable (though I think the Note 3 still won on some factors). If they had actually delivered it around the original planned time it wouldn't have been so bad but it was very late -- covid of course can take some of the blame but not all, and anyway there's another ongoing supply chain shortage right now such that even big companies like Valve can't easily source sufficient components, so why would this time around be any different for Purism.

AFAIK they did start to honor refund requests at some point, but by the time I was forced to upgrade from my Note 3 (due to cell networks) I had already written it off in my mind as an open source donation since at least Purism was doing things more properly than other attempts (Ubuntu, Mozilla) with a lot of upstreaming of changes. The thing eventually arrived and I messed around with it a bit but it's mostly sat in a box for years now. v2 is already way too late... unfortunately for them they won't get more money from me. Also not a fan of the deceptive use of the verb "launched" for a crowdfunding page, nor the emails they spammed me with over the years about some scammy "investment opportunity" or whatever it was, nor the founder's behaviors, nor the mistreatment of former employees...