logoalt Hacker News

Imustaskforhelp • today at 8:30 PM • 0 replies • view on HN

Haha very interesting observation, I think that there is a challenge to status quo.

Just my 2 cents:

I think that our first reactions to seeing these companies model releases is that of skepticism and somewhat rightfully so because these companies have done a lot of things to burn a lot of trust.

But AI is still important and so if someone is on Anthropic, they might feel as if Opus 5.5/Fable 5.2 is good and so if OAI is saying Astra 6.2 is better/comparable to them, a persons first instinct is to not trust OAI which might mean siding with Anthropic.

And if Anthropic releases a model, then there would be more discussions on pricing because somehow that is also related to bubble popping. I mean, supposing I can get good enough model at 10x the cheaper price of Anthropic from OAI for very marginal points, ofc people will comment about that as well.

And within both the threads we will find an intersection of discussion of open-weights models as well.

But maybe this is that if a model is just released and as such we are not having real use and word of mouth after real use from other people (which takes time), so our first instincts is to not trust any of the company so much and benchmarks can be cheated through and sometimes inaccurate of real world usage so we are in for a surprise when a new model drops and so we just drop back to those first reactions that I mentioned previously.

But this was a good question that you asked! and I would be curious to hear other person's observations

but mine (TLDR) is that: people distrust both OAI/ANT and other AI companies in HN. (Maybe we are technical people and we tend to look beyond the BS of marketing and so we think that we wont be impacted by that BS so we want to call out that BS but we dont know for sure if its BS or not but judging by the fact that these AI companies have incredibly low trusts, we as default don't really trust them and consider them BS and so the chain follows.)

HN audience is a tough audience to satisfy from first impressions (real world usage imo becomes a much better indicator and we do see it as people mention other models in this thread and others) ;)