logoalt Hacker News

nixosbestos • today at 3:44 AM • 2 replies • view on HN

People are reading the article, or the first few sentences, right?

> Wall Street executives and the National Security Agency have told members of Congress that this week’s widespread tech outages were caused by attempts to fix vulnerabilities identified by artificial intelligence, according to three sources familiar with the private conversations.

aka, possibly rushed patches/patching, in response to AI-discovered vulns. As far as I can tell "AI-authored patches" is not really mentioned in this article. (Whether that's true or not, I won't speculate, but it's weird to see the several comments just jumping on "AI patching bad".)


Replies

perrygeo • today at 4:19 AM

Exactly! A vulnerability was identified. Company patched the vulnerability, but messed up in the process.

The vulnerability was identified by AI but it existed before. Not clear if the company used AI to write the patch. The causal role of AI is zero. They responded with bad code that caused a broken system. Their testing should have caught the regression. If it didn't, they need better tests.

This is a testing/QA failure, orthogonal to AI issues. I don't deny that the pace of AI-revealed vulnerabilities increases the pressure to rush out patches. But the response to vulnerabilities is entirely in the hands of the operators and test writers. Take some responsibility FFS.

bagacrap • today at 3:56 AM

It doesn't say it, but I assume the engineers in question are just hitting "ok go with your top recommendation".