logoalt Hacker News

RetroTechie • today at 10:28 AM • 1 reply • view on HN

Stopped buying disposable batteries years ago & never looked back. Have seen too many devices over time whose battery contacts were nuked due to leaking alkalines.

It used to be that NiMH's weren't good for long-standby, low power applications like TV remotes, digital clocks & the like. That hasn't been true since the introduction of low self-discharge ("precharged", "stay charged" etc) NiMH's a decade+ ago (pro tip: Eneloop Lite is perfect for such uses).

Some people claim that NiMH's lower output voltage is a problem. That's nonsense: practically any device designed to take AA/AAA will work down to ~1.1...1.0V, at which point NiMH is empty. At higher current draw, NiMH's tend to compare favourably against alkalines.

It does pay to invest in a good charger, and avoid no-name brands though. In order of personal preference: Eneloop, japanese-MADE like Sanyo/Panasonic or Fujitsu, then respected brands like Duracell. Don't bother with non-LSD cells, and cheapo brands aren't worth the risk of quality/performance issues.

Most people who don't opt for rechargeables, base their opinion on experience with NiMHs from 20y ago, crappy chargers, outdated info, or have money to burn & are simply lazy. Even that last point is questionable: I consider it easier to just pop a few cells in a charger & use, than head off to a store to buy disposables.

For consumer uses, alkaline has no place in modern society imho. Technology has advanced, rechargeables are cheap, good & easy now.


Replies

eternityforest • today at 10:46 AM

The important thing to note is that a "good charger" doesn't just mean from a trusted brand, it has to charge the batteries individually.

Otherwise, if it charges two in series, and you have a device that needs three, you'll probably eventually mismatch the charge levels.

If you ruin a battery it will be hard to find the bad one without a tester, and your charger won't help you if it can't measure individual cells...

I still prefer alkaline for anything that only needs replacing every 15 years though. I use NiMh in my mouse but alkaline in things I use once a year for a few minutes, like my pocket multimeter.