logoalt Hacker News

swatcoder • today at 3:27 PM • 2 replies • view on HN

Yes, but casual users won't give more detailed prompting until and unless the AI asks them for it.

Someone like a software professional using AI every day is going to develop better instincts about how the AI works and what it needs, but the casual person who saw an ChatGPT superbowl ad and installed the app for occassional self-help questions, or for a couple document tasks a week for their job, isn't going to have that sense.

They're going to ask everyday questions in everyday language, and in many cases, they're going to get garbage/misleading "frequentist" answers like this by default.

So it's a real problem worth bringing to wider general attention, and a real problem that AI tool designers are working to address in their response formatting (like the refining questions you'll often see appended to Google AI overview output).


Replies

asdff • today at 5:29 PM

Theres also an assumption that even someone who is a software engineer working with ai every day knows their prompts are even insufficient. This is the issue with this stuff. “You have to figure out how to prompt better” is actually a really stupid way to work with a tool.

paganel • today at 3:35 PM

> in everyday language

While in general I agree with your comment, isn't one of the main points of those current AI tools the fact that they can be "worked with" using everyday language? I.e. no need for esoteric (from the pov of a "normal" person) "if/else" clauses or other such computer programmer-ish concepts translated to AI prompts.

➕ show 1 reply