logoalt Hacker News

pingou • today at 4:19 PM • 14 replies • view on HN

That doesn't seem to make much sense. Why would Ukraine attack Poland? There may be some tensions between Poland and Ukraine, but there need to be some degree of plausibility to a false flag operation.

If that was real it would probably make Poland support Ukraine even more or even declare war on Russia.


Replies

avgDev • today at 4:24 PM

I have been to Poland just over a year ago, there are people who definitely are upset about Ukrainians in the country. I've heard complaints that country is giving them money, they are taking jobs and the women are stealing men. An attack might be hard to believe for an outsider, however, if you already have a negative view, it might further drive your opinion that helping Ukraine is bad.

➕ show 7 replies
rdtsc • today at 5:13 PM

> Why would Ukraine attack Poland?

They were not historically as friendly as you may imagine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volhynian_Bloody_Sunday

In light of the war with Russia, Ukrainian govt has been leaning more into bolstering various individuals from the past who have had nationalistic leanings (you can read that in any flavor you'd like).

(from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ukrainian_Insurgent_Army)

> On 20 October 2026, local deputies of the Lviv Regional Council supported a resolution to designate 2027 as the Year of the Ukrainian Insurgent Army (UPA) and its commander-in-chief, Roman Shukhevych.

It's kind of a sensitive topic, certainly, and the Russians will not fail to take advantage of this crack and try to "widen" it a bit, if you will. A false flag attack is a pretty bold move. Don't know if it means they are desperate.

➕ show 1 reply
Emma_Goldman • today at 4:58 PM

The story is that the attack would have been on the Polish border with Kaliningrad, an exclave Russian territory. To have any plausibility, I suppose it would have to attack shared infrastructure, of which there's not much, or been staged as an accident.

Of course, this is unconfirmed and garbled. It comes third or fourth hand from an English-language source relaying a Polish source relaying Polish intelligence acquired from foreign intelligence services.

pavel_lishin • today at 4:26 PM

It's nearly impossible to have any sort of theory about this without knowing the details, which are obviously not going to be shared out any time soon.

postepowanieadm • today at 6:06 PM

Ukrainians using Polish territory to launch an attack on russia could cause some tensions.

dmos62 • today at 4:22 PM

You can spin it in social media and lots of people will believe it. It's unreal to me too, but disinformation is super effective and Russia is expert at it. You don't need the majority to believe it, anything to fuel division is enough.

➕ show 1 reply
kergonath • today at 4:46 PM

> That doesn't seem to make much sense. Why would Ukraine attack Poland?

The aims of Russia here is to sow doubt and distrust. It does not need to be bulletproof, just muddy enough to provide talking points for their agents and useful idiots. The relationship between Poland and Ukraine is… complicated. What brings them together is mostly that they hate Russia more.

benterix • today at 5:43 PM

>That doesn't seem to make much sense

Neither does SIM cards presented as The Sims games:

https://nypost.com/2022/04/25/russia-appears-to-confuse-the-...

But it doesn't matter, they do it anyway and are quite effective as the far right has considerable support in various parts of Europe.

saalweachter • today at 4:25 PM

Double false flag? Maybe it was supposed to be Russians pretending to be Ukrainians pretending to be Russians, to make it look like Russia was being framed for attacking Poland in an attempt to increase Polish support for the war, so that when the one layer of false-flag was peeled back it would create a backlash against Ukraine?

➕ show 1 reply
ozim • today at 5:44 PM

You are smart.

Now explain the same to dozens of stupid people who will see “evidence” from the site to fuel disinformation and then all the stupid people who will pass that disinformation.

Then take casualties into account - you think that relatives of people killed in such attack will analyze geopolitical environment when they they are pointed to “obvious evidence”?

That’s naivety.

Tanjreeve • today at 5:19 PM

It doesn’t matter if i makes sense. You just need to sow enough confusion for actions to get bogged down in debate. Same as when russia invaded in 2014 and english speaking social media was utterly saturated with how this was a spontaneous local militia who had overwhelmed the Ukranian army and somehow aquired the latest special forces equipment.

alephnerd • today at 4:40 PM

The aim was to kill a couple Russian citizens and then blame Ukraine via plausible deniability [0].

Tactically, it likely would have been paying a couple Ukrainians working in the black market (sadly very common across Europe) to conduct a high casualty event on Russian civilians in Kalinigrad and Poland and then blame it on Ukraine via a mixture of money trail and metadata.

A good example of this is the 2025 Pahalgam attack [1] in Indian Kashmir which led to the 2025 Indo-Pak War - India had a difficult time building the diplomatic case for the conflict because of plausible deniability from the attackers.

Some HNers just don't realize how precarious stuff is at the moment [2].

[0] - https://www.rp.pl/konflikty-zbrojne/art45490041-prowokacja-z...

[1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2025_Pahalgam_attack

[2] - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50538994#50539922

mzs • today at 5:34 PM

https://tvpworld.com/96545106/russia-planned-false-flag-atta...

But Moscow could have accused Ukraine of attacking Russia from Polish territory, blamed Warsaw for allowing it and threatened retaliation.

Or Russia could even have launched a subsequent attack on a target in Poland, the alleged source of the Ukrainian attack. This would have confronted NATO with a serious crisis, while Moscow could claim to have been defending itself.

This is precisely the sort of test of NATO solidarity that allied leaders have warned about.

By manufacturing uncertainty over who attacked whom, Moscow could have sown doubts among member states, delayed a collective response and exposed divisions over whether Article 5 should be invoked.

...

The methods are becoming increasingly brazen. Earlier this month, Polish investigators arrested two Ukrainians accused of setting vehicles alight on Russian orders, having first fitted them with number plates resembling those of the Ukrainian army.

Prosecutors believe the idea was to turn Polish public opinion against Ukraine.

mik1998 • today at 4:46 PM

[flagged]

➕ show 3 replies