logoalt Hacker News

jader201 • today at 4:34 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

Except the whole point — or at least arguably the biggest point — of SimCity is optimization.

Most speedran games aren’t designed for speedrunning. But people do it anyway. The goal by design in many of these games is to simply beat the game, with a secondary goal of completing any side quests (e.g. 100%-ing the game).

Speedrunning is often not a goal of the designers (though most know it will be a goal for some players).

SimCity asks to be optimized. You want your city to flourish, which means finding ways to optimize your design.

Yes, this often means a more realistic design, and yes at some point that optimization crosses into counterintuitive designs. But that’s a line the player must draw, as it’s not always super clear, especially for people that don’t fully know what a realistic optimal city design looks like.


Replies

Waterluvian • today at 5:14 PM

Maybe. For me it’s only ever been about aesthetics competing with the constraint that the city has to be plausible.

A lot of the game mechanics and tools become traps if you only care about optimization. And you end up just figuring out what systems matter and what their parameters are. Sure that’s valid. There is no wrong way to play a game. But for me it is optimizing the fun out of the game.