logoalt Hacker News

Madmallard • today at 4:35 PM • 6 replies • view on HN

Vaccinations ABSOLUTELY are not meant to strengthen people.

They are a specific choice. An intentional alteration of the immune system to prevent the POSSIBLE risk of contracting a virus either to yourself or to those around you with weakened immune systems.

In an environment where ZERO cases of measles, HPV, rubella, COVID, influenza, rabies, tetanus etc. are present or will be present (like a deserted island), it would unarguably be worse for the individual's overall health and long-term viability to vaccinate them to all of these things than to avoid taking them altogether.

This is something that people, as we're becoming increasingly aware, are less and less okay with.

We know that snakes are running the world and destabilizing our systems. We know our environment is being destroyed, every company is selfish and would rather their losses and risks be diverted to the general population than themselves. Everyone's getting screwed over in some way already. No one wants to get screwed over. It's unfortunately a globally adversarial environment.

Technological advances have a cost themselves. People are deeming that cost acceptable independently of what people who might be harmed by it think.


Replies

edu • today at 5:11 PM

Yeah, you’re right.

But we don’t live in a desert island, you’re starting we a false premise and then the rest of the argument fails.

With vaccination you make indivuals stronger in front or certain infections, and the society as a whole too as those that cannot be vaccinated for proper health reasons have a smaller chance of being infected.

Also, that the reason you’re not mandated to take all available vaccines depending on the risks on your region. I.e. yellow fever.

If humans had perfect immune systems vaccines wouldn’t be necessary either.

noboostforyou • today at 5:15 PM

> Vaccinations ABSOLUTELY are not meant to strengthen people.

Are you being unnecessarily pedantic about the definition of "strengthen"? Vaccinations strengthen people and society as a whole, I presume you have heard of the concept of herd immunity. When people stop getting vaccinated it leads to more people being at risk for sickness or even death. For example, people are not vaccinating their kids and now we have an increase in Measles-related deaths - https://www.cdc.gov/measles/data-research/index.html

> In an environment where ZERO cases of measles, HPV, rubella, COVID, influenza, rabies, tetanus etc. are present or will be present (like a deserted island), it would unarguably be worse for the individual's overall health and long-term viability to vaccinate them

This is a moot example, almost no one lives in such an environment.

wnmurphy • today at 5:20 PM

> intentional alteration of the immune system

This is a really slanted way to describe how vaccines work. You're showing your immune system deactivated examples of the actual virus, so that it learns it, so that it can defeat it when the virus is encountered.

> This is something that people, as we're becoming increasingly aware, are less and less okay with.

Due to the spread of disinformation, sure. But these people are a minority.

> In an environment where ZERO cases of measles, HPV, rubella, COVID, influenza, rabies, tetanus etc. are present or will be present (like a deserted island), it would unarguably be worse for the individual's overall health and long-term viability to vaccinate them to all of these things than to avoid taking them altogether.

This is a contrived hypothetical. That's not how the world works, and you're also begging the question that vaccination by itself is worse than actual virus exposure, which is just common misinformation.

Vaccines are a profound live-saving technology, and the benefit to society has been thoroughly proven at this point. Measles vaccination alone has saved about 94 million lives.

mainmailman • today at 5:19 PM

You’re astoundingly simple minded. No one lives on a desert island free of disease, so saying that as some sort of rhetorical framing isn’t relevant to talking about real things in the real world.

Have fun making things up in your own head to make you feel smart, though.

Dylan16807 • today at 5:26 PM

> In an environment [...] like a deserted island

Yeah if things were different then things would be different.

brlewis • today at 6:47 PM

>Vaccinations ABSOLUTELY are not meant to strengthen people.

Doing pushups, I notice that I'm weaker when I'm sick. Vaccination for me and my community is meant to help me be less sick. You'll need a lot more caps lock to convince me of your point, even with a narrow definition of "strengthen".