But I am confused, I thought arxiv was meant for preprints of novel research to be published, I did not know you can push manuscripts of established science to it ?
It is worse. Now everyone and their dog are publishing there crackpot science too. There is a minimal filtration because you need an invitation from someone that is already using it or a special case approval, but after that you can publish good stuff, or elementary obvious boring stuff or good review stuff or totally crackpot stuff. It's just WordPress for PDF.
Now they are trying to keep the level above zero, so they had now a policy that bans someone if their clancker adds too many fake references. It's a minimal filter, but apparently it is enough to filter the worst of the worst.
There is also good stuff there, but unless you know the area and the author and take a view of the content, you can not take any PDF posted there at face value.
It is worse. Now everyone and their dog are publishing there crackpot science too. There is a minimal filtration because you need an invitation from someone that is already using it or a special case approval, but after that you can publish good stuff, or elementary obvious boring stuff or good review stuff or totally crackpot stuff. It's just WordPress for PDF.
Now they are trying to keep the level above zero, so they had now a policy that bans someone if their clancker adds too many fake references. It's a minimal filter, but apparently it is enough to filter the worst of the worst.
There is also good stuff there, but unless you know the area and the author and take a view of the content, you can not take any PDF posted there at face value.