logoalt Hacker News

pixl97 • today at 6:53 PM • 2 replies • view on HN

>So then ban them (the products).

Ah yes, wonderful idea like the serious AI safety people have been saying for a while.

The problem is 'just ban' doesn't work that way. Cigarrets were killing tons of people for decades and the tobacco companies fought back and made that process very difficult. Maybe, maybe in the US after our change in congress we'll see some action on this.

>"but we still want to ban people we don't like from using it".

Get over it, the world is filled with shit like this. There are countless 'dangerous' products that I cannot buy as an individual without a license, so at best you'll push LLMs to monied interests and those with wealth why you cut yourself out. Worse militaries have got a taste, authoritarians have got a taste, government security agencies have got a taste. They'll keep building them with black budgets and using them against their enemies/the public/whoever they want forever.


Replies

za_creature • today at 7:12 PM

I'm under no impression that banning them will make them go away. But, like nuclear non-proliferation, it creates diplomatic options.

The cops can figure out whether you're growing weed by your energy usage patterns or, failing that, via your heat output. Availability of GPUs and talent aside, there's simply no universe in which you're training LLMs without anyone being able to figure it out.

And just because the world is filled with shit like this, doesn't mean it has to be. Money helps get a lot of heads looking the other way, but that's in short supply these days. And it doesn't take a genius to guess where it all went.

skinfaxi • today at 6:55 PM

So the people making the AI are the tobacco companies in your analogy? If AI is so dangerous, couldn't they just....stop making it? "But someone else will do it!" can be said for literally anything.