logoalt Hacker News

rvz • yesterday at 8:44 PM • 5 replies • view on HN

Yet another WebKit-based browser. Why? We already have Orion [0] that does exactly what this one does.

Also why WebKit? It has monthly memory corruption vulnerabilities being discovered.

Why not just improve Ladybird? [0] instead of creating a worse version of existing browsers that still suffer from weekly memory corruption vulnerabilities.

[0] https://orionbrowser.com/

[1] https://ladybird.org/


Replies

pmkary • yesterday at 9:28 PM

Many years ago when Brave had just came out and it was an Electron browser---and Electron had like 10 use cases world wide---I was so frustrated with browsers that I thought man I can fork this and just fix it for myself. It wasn't about a revolutionary thing like Ladybird or if Brave was good foundation; it was only the lowest hanging fruit for me, the only possible one back then. I couldn't even fathom compiling Chromium, not to mention changing it.

WebKit is designed to be easily embedded, is already compiled in the mac and has a very straight forward API and is a part of Apple world, so you just make the browser shell and what you want. That is probably the rationale behind 99% of WebKit browsers. Search was 6MB worth of download, you can't have that with Chromium, and I don't think if people have the patience to use a half done browser engine so that it can be finished---although I personally am counting down for the day I switch to ladybird.

rsaz • yesterday at 9:20 PM

I do like Orion as well, but it's substantially larger (580 MB vs 11MB for me) and isn't open source.

Anecdotally, I also like Search's look better and have found it more stable (though it's been a while since I really tried using Orion to be fair).

➕ show 1 reply
Squarex • yesterday at 8:47 PM

It consumes less memory than Blink on macOS.

hxorr • yesterday at 9:54 PM

Uhh.. I would argue that we don't have /enough/ Webkit based browsers. There are currently no Webkit browsers for Windows unless you want to run Something like Gnome web/Epiphany in WSL.

Kagi Orion looked promising, but they quit developing their windows version recently.

driceroland • yesterday at 8:52 PM

fair question. orion is great, and closed source. Search is MIT-licensed, ~10 mb, and built around arc’s way of working (spaces, pins, split view, peek, arc import), plus chrome extensions. on webkit: it’s the engine macos ships and patches with each security update, so Search gets those fixes without us maintaining an engine. that’s a big part of why we picked it.