> Historical arguments for routine carry from the days when the Constitution was written are thus weak.
So the 4th amendment that says this:
"... secure in their persons, houses, papers, ..."
doesn't concern digital information because the notion of information stored digitally and not in paper wasn't envisioned by the Constitution?
Same for the 1st amendment in modern times. Try this version: "Historical arguments for free online speech from the days when the Constitution was written are thus weak."
We're in this weird legal hangover because the greatest generation through boomers never saw a power they didn't think the .gov should have and contorted everything to that end but I expect that in the next 20-40yr we'll have precedents that unwind those boondoggles and get our digital stuff protected the same way that bank and telecom stuff is.