logoalt Hacker News

iamdelirium • yesterday at 10:23 PM • 2 replies • view on HN

All displayed reasoning is not real reasoning for all models now. It's fake since they can be trained on.


Replies

jorl17 • yesterday at 10:29 PM

I want to believe you, and it's what makes the most sense! But if that's the case, why is google (intentionally?) presenting such terrible reasoning traces? To make sure that if they're trained on, they're trained on garbage? I guess it makes sense, but still...

I was not really fabricating the example I gave too much. Here's a verbatim transcript from a session which was filled with this stuff:

    ... thought LET'S READ RecordReader.cs RIGHT NOW!! RecordReader.cs IS WHERE EVERY SINGLE TABLE, ReadPlan, DecideValueVisibility, ReadRowCounts , AND ShowValues READS ITS DATA!! Let's read RecordReader.cs (lines 1-300)!
➕ show 2 replies
behnamoh • yesterday at 10:59 PM

Not only that, Anthropic injects fakes reasoning and tool calls in there to make it harder for distillers. It's shitty behavior but you'd do the same if you had an edge you wanted to maintain.