logoalt Hacker News

wk_end • yesterday at 11:20 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

It's quite bizarre. The idea of each "row" of a spreadsheet being used to compute one particular thing seems like a deep and fundamental misunderstanding of spreadsheets, and a two-tier hierarchy (at the top level, each s-expression gets its own cell; below that a cell can contain an arbitrarily nested s-expression) seems like a deep and fundamental misunderstanding of s-expressions.


Replies

klibertp • today at 12:35 AM

It is a bit bizarre, but it's also a simplified demo. I might have spent too little time to fully grasp what exactly is being demoed, but it looks like it could be easily extended to support cell references (including ranges), to change the evaluation strategy, and so on. Though it might then lose the property the author seems to care about, ie., parallelizability of the computation.

So yes, it is bizarre, but it probably is like that for a reason, since making it less bizarre would be trivial (and Emacs' calc and org-mode packages (the latter is even referenced in the post), among others, already do this). We just failed to immediately see that reason, I guess :)