logoalt Hacker News

We need smart people who give a shit

180 points • by ExMachina73 • yesterday at 11:53 PM • 88 comments • view on HN

Comments

noisy_boy • today at 12:09 AM

Based on what I see in the workplaces nowadays, people who give a shit are treated like shit. Give a shit about your own wellbeing instead first and if there is still some left to give, sure throw it at the project.

➕ show 8 replies
c2h5oh • today at 12:15 AM

We have them.

They are sidelined, because giving a shit is not reflected in OKRs and giving a shit often equals standing in a way of "good enough" as judged by a middle manager and thus committing mortal sin of not focusing on getting to market faster.

➕ show 2 replies
janalsncm • today at 12:23 AM

In the workplace there are three kinds of people: people who don’t care, people who care about climbing the ladder, and people who care about the quality of the product they’re creating.

In a perfect world, the second and third group would be the same, but since impressions of competence are lossy as information travels up the hierarchy, optimizing for the impression of competence (i.e. “visibility”) will always be more rewarded than actual competence.

➕ show 5 replies
GarnetFloride • today at 12:33 AM

Some people might think that having smart people who give a shit would be a good thing. But there are perverse incentives in the way.

A CEO might know that keeping smart people is a good thing. But the incentive structure for the directors and other middle management just make it impossible because smart people get expensive and tossing them looks good for those middle management bonuses.

Smart people are opinionated, and management thinks very highly of themselves so they can't have anyone with "bad vibes" around.

Of course there are more. So what can you do?

➕ show 1 reply
george_max • today at 12:21 AM

We've had spectacular infrastructure outages for decades; I think that a cluster of incidents in one week doesn't establish that AI is directly responsible for declining reliability.

IMO, the issue is that AI is reducing the cost of building and modifying systems much faster than it's reducing the cost of understanding them. For example, an engineer can work on a problem or project for a week that could otherwise be done by AI in an hour or so. But, that week spent was not "wasted time"; it was understanding what it is they are building, discovering undocumented assumptions, knowing about different dependencies, developing intuitions about the system and how it works, etc.

This causes comprehension debt. Yes, the system does ultimately work, the tests also pass. But the level of comprehension goes down significantly.

That said, AI can also help reduce this debt by asking it what you need help understanding.

A good blog post on this: https://larsfaye.com/articles/ai-coding-will-prevent-experti...

➕ show 2 replies
alphazard • today at 12:42 AM

This framing that we have smart people, who don't give a shit, is a little out of touch with the reality in industry right now.

There are plenty of smart people, but you probably aren't paying them enough to argue and play politics with the imposters that you have also hired. If doing something well also requires convincing a (product) manager that it was their idea, then no one will be doing anything well. The best are going to checkout.

If you get rid of the imposters and lessen the cognitive burden of playing politics to get anything done, it will appear as though all your smart folks started caring.

eddythompson80 • today at 12:27 AM

To me this has been the main outcome of AI. Think how big software development has changed for ever, think how big product prototyping and planing has changed forever, think about research, math, etc. all huge changes.

Yet the thing is rate at the top of how AI have revealed to me that in an organization of 400 people, 3 give a shit. I literally can’t find anyone who gives a shit in insanity large organizations. Not low paid entry workers, not partner or VP, not CEOs. All just a bunch of people who probably never gave a shit to begin with, but AI put that at the forefront.

proc0 • today at 12:01 AM

I think in part it's the industry's attitude towards software engineering, and undervalueing technical work. Most companies do this by adding more responsibilities than just building the software and maintaining it as if that isn't hard enough. It's everything from managing the project to being repsonsible for releasing and communicating the changes. People have limited time to specialize and become experts in the systems they build and slicing products vertically so that each engineer has a tiny slice of the entire business is producing fragile systems across the industry.

➕ show 4 replies
plandis • today at 12:28 AM

> And collapse is what we're starting to see. Some recent examples of various failures from just this past week or so: Microsoft 365, Air Traffic Control, United Airlines' systems, the NSA's network, many major banks, Apple's systems, and more. We're told these failures and problems are not related. They're not the result of a cyberattack. They're not the fault of generative AI.

In my personal experience the intelligent people are making data driven factual arguments. Without root cause analysis of these various failures I don’t see how one can conclude it’s due to uncaring, unintelligent people. I’ve seen plenty of failures that are due to unforeseen issues that come up despite having caring, intelligent people owning those systems.

CalChris • today at 1:08 AM

Capitalism doesn’t care about employees. They are a cost of doing business.

compass_copium • today at 12:51 AM

I don't think it's just AI, workers in general bounce around more so they don't have the same depth of knowledge in their systems, companies don't invest nearly as much in their training, faster release cycles don't reward stable systems as much as constant tweaking. AI is certainly not going to help any of that, and I think it's poised to make all of that a lot worse, but I don't think it's the cause of it all quite yet.

HoldOnAMinute • today at 12:54 AM

I don't know if we would all agree on the definition of "smart people".

One of us would say a "smart" person is Bert Cooper type who is completely self-interested.

Another might say a "smart" person maximizes the outcome for themselves and for the group. (John Nash equilibrium)

Both of these might argue that they being "smart"

andai • today at 12:12 AM

You just need people who put more energy into reality than simulacra.

➕ show 2 replies
hyperbole • today at 12:15 AM

Life is like a sewer, what you get out of it, depends on what you put into it... -Tom Lehrer

➕ show 2 replies
throwawaypty • today at 12:39 AM

Complex systems won't survive the competency crisis. People like the author of TFA are the religious zealots whose fundamentalism got us here in the first place: https://www.palladiummag.com/2023/06/01/complex-systems-wont...

➕ show 1 reply
bix6 • today at 12:20 AM

1. I don’t agree this is necessarily due to AI. PE has hollowed out every industry. Take a great business, fire everyone, mine it, let it die.

2. The “smart” people at the top are generally selfish assholes. They abuse the system and others to self enrich. We don’t need more smart people, we need more caring people.

3. Nobody gives a shit anymore. The older generations fucked it up and are aging out and just saying haha sorry we messed it up but good luck while I chill in my 7th vacation home. The young are jaded because all the jobs are dogshit and underpaid. The only way to win is to get rich overnight on Kalshi or crypto or futures or whatever. Why would you work for most of these horrible companies? It’s not worth your life.

4. Look at POTUS. Grift on grift. Everything falls apart in a society that runs on grift. They couldn’t even re-line a pool…

dwoldrich • today at 12:35 AM

All my opinions:

We need smart people who give a shit, demonstrate good taste, and welcome "but why??" challenges to their ideas with confident, well-developed, reasonable answers.

We don't need cowboys. We don't need ivory tower religious fanatics. We don't need big mouths who win arguments with aggression or oppression olympics emotional blackmail. If you want to lead, lead with grace, otherwise follow your leader with equal aplomb.

While we no longer have the time nor energy for any bullcrap due to AI slop, we see and appreciate when AI is used well.

The greatest predictor of wealth is age. If you're a young buck and feeling pinched, invest in yourself, go heads-down on work for five or ten years, and build them skills and good taste - you'll end up very happy with the results. Don't let the turkeys get you down!

jareklupinski • today at 12:09 AM

it seems once you're smart enough in a niche or field worth investing in (giving a sht about), you're either paid to keep the status quo just as it is, or you're branded a heretic who wants nothing more than to cost people their jobs

jmclnx • today at 12:45 AM

Lets see:

1. No job security. You will be fired for increased short term profit.

2. Pay is low, many people can barely get by.

3. You are forced to work pretty much all your waking hours.

4. and now with AI, who knows what the future holds.

And people wonder why employees do not care about anything these days.

aspbee555 • today at 12:28 AM

I was shit on for giving a shit.

I worked for a safety equipment manufacturer for over a decade. I did everything, programming, servers, network, machine maintenance/repair, etc. I transitioned them from a 20 year old accounting system with 10k SKU/20k BOM to a new ERP system with zero downtime. My reward? nasty discrimination and forced to quit

I used to be proud of my ability to do a wide variety of technical work, programming, systems, servers, industrial machines, industrial controllers, lasers, molding machines, etc. Nothing was beyond my understanding. All I got for all my hard work and skills was shit on

AI has been great for programming tasks and the software I have worked on for years (I just enjoy programming for programming sake, would be nice if I could be paid for my skills instead of judged for how well/poorly I lie/ass kiss)

It kills me I was forced to stop giving a shit. The sycophantic AI is perfect for what businesses really want.

➕ show 1 reply
levkk • today at 12:15 AM

I would revise the thesis to add: we need smart people who give a shit and are willing to go the distance. It can take 5 years to modernize ACH. You have to commit and stick with it.

0sake_rs • today at 12:24 AM

Thank you for putting how I feel into words so well

jagged-chisel • today at 12:17 AM

> Capitalism does, however begrudgingly, recognize that smart people who give a shit are required to build and maintain complex systems that serve capitalist goals.

Ha! No, it doesn't. The moment that the capital owners can bisect responsibility enough that each cog can be replaced with an "equivalent" (read: younger/recently graduated, capable of typing code) cog, the smart and caring are discarded. This is because People With Opinions can derail the goals of the investors; because Smart People begin to understand just how pointless the ISOs are.

The founder with the engineering intelligence and the business intelligence to build their vision is the only one who stays stealthy and small, needn't take investors, needn't hire dozens of additional engineers.

➕ show 1 reply
MinimalAction • today at 12:30 AM

In academia, I am realizing that giving a shit now is futile. People write back to you with their AI assisted random gibberish to sound smart and it has been hard to know if the breadth is organically acquired or artificially synthesized. Depth has always been hard to emulate and it shall remain so.

Those who give a shit and care, I feel are going to burn out by this system. I wish there was a simpler answer for less privileged folks out there.

neuralkoi • today at 12:04 AM

I think we need wise people who give a shit. Intelligence is overrated.

➕ show 3 replies
wjb3 • today at 12:03 AM

"As the twenty-first century began, human evolution was at a turning point. Natural selection, the process by which the strongest, the smartest, the fastest reproduced in greater numbers than the rest, a process which had once favored the noblest traits of man, now began to favor different traits. Most science fiction of the day predicted a future that was more civilized and more intelligent. But, as time went on, things seemed to be heading in the opposite direction. A dumbing down. How did this happen? Evolution does not necessarily reward intelligence. With no natural predators to thin the herd, it began to simply reward those who reproduced the most, and left the intelligent to become an endangered species."

IYKYK

➕ show 1 reply
BLKNSLVR • today at 12:21 AM

In my experience smart people who give a shit tend to rub management the wrong way because they "negatively effect velocity". Ironically, when they're treated like that they stop giving a shit or quit and find somewhere better to work. Neither option is 'better for long term velocity'.

Flemlord • today at 12:08 AM

A modernized version of Smart and Gets Things Done: https://www.cse.unr.edu/~sushil/researchAdvice/GIV1.html

Of which, there is also a modernized version: https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2000/03/23/the-guerrilla-guid...

➕ show 1 reply
andai • today at 12:13 AM

> there aren't enough smart people who give a shit.

There aren't enough humans who are smarter than the machines.

That situation gets worse every week.

svnt • today at 12:27 AM

When VCs started investing in eg former Bridgewater employees over tech founders, the writing was on the wall.

It is a status club now, and giving a shit does not make you one of the cool kids. Giving a shit is papered over as an “ego spike” and cool kids don’t have those, because they make sure not to take the risk of insisting on anything.

jacquesm • today at 12:09 AM

Let's call it Effective Altruism. Who could possibly disagree with that?

Guess who is in charge of the AI companies?

boothby • today at 12:22 AM

We need smart people who give a shit like the shipbuilding industry needed tall trees. If you think there’s a dearth it’s because you treated them like an infinite resource.

But no, we need wise leadership not just "smart people." We smart peopled our way into this mess.

matheusmoreira • today at 12:13 AM

People say this but in reality it's all about time to market. It's all about doing things as fast as humanly possible. Well, as fast as agentically possible, I guess.

Giving a shit actively gets in the way of that. If you care too much about things, then you're going to waste time focusing on things that don't actually make any money instead of shipping.

I wish companies would hire a professional shit giver whose sole task is to care about things and nurture them, make things better overall. It doesn't seem like they're ever going to do that, though.

andreygrehov • today at 12:16 AM

I give a shit, but nobody gives a shit about me giving a shit.

➕ show 1 reply
jiggawatts • today at 12:18 AM

I noticed something happening over the last two decades: as improved automation and efficiency allowed fewer technical people to "do more", the ratio of technical to non-technical staff has shifted to the latter.

It's to the point now that I regularly see large and complex systems being built by essentially one guy but with dozens of "managers" overseeing his solo work. I've been in meetings with "project coordinators", "project managers", "governance", "change control managers", etc... all on the same single-product team and only one person there actually "presses the buttons".

This has shifted power and decision making away from the "smart people who give a shit" over to the "politicians that like to play Game of Thrones In The Workplace".

Look around you and see if you can spot more of these "inverted pyramids" with the point at the bottom: one technical person at the bottom "managed" by a team, which in turn has an even larger layer of managers above them, etc.

➕ show 1 reply
jcarmackdaddy • today at 12:52 AM

"Giving a shit" leads to being banned for having opinions.

hn_throwaway_99 • today at 12:36 AM

While I am sympathetic to the general thesis of this article (especially as someone who used to be knee deep in the ACH spec!), I can't help but find it amusing how I've now seen probably 4 or 5 posts now explaining how these recent outages are proof of Author's Pet Theory.

This is a gentle reminder that none of this is true. Step one would be to try to determine if the recent outages are more than what would be expected by random chance (which none of these articles ever do), or if now you're hearing a lot more about every little outage in an attempt from reporters to craft a narrative (e.g. the MS 365 outage and FAA ground stops were noticeable anomalies, but after that it felt like reporters were just refreshing downdetector for new stories, e.g. the Apple services outage was relatively small and short lived).

I've read other theories that many of the recent outages are due to increased release pressure from companies needing to patch systems since AI is finding lots of long-standing vulnerabilities. Again, certainly plausible, and that plausible explanation is just as plausible as OP's opposite plausible explanation.

ethin • today at 12:36 AM

I don't think it's fair or reasonable to blame this on AI. You can give a shit about how what you have an agent make for you works. It is possible to use AI and (not) produce slop, even if some will claim otherwise. I would even go so far as to say that slop as a term has been so overused that it doesn't mean anything anymore.

The tech industry as a whole hasn't gave a shit for decades. Oh sure, every good company gave a shit at some point, but then the shareholders started calling and begging for more and more cash and, well, here we are. All AI has done is make visible the symptoms of not giving a shit that people conveniently ignore for the longest time until it affects them. Until Capitalism is either abolished outright or very deeply regulated so that people can actually give a shit again, I sadly don't see this changing. And yes, I know, I know, I did say regulated. I'm sure some will hate that. But just letting capitalism reign free is also not going to work.

carterschonwald • today at 12:10 AM

people who give a shit need to be paid money.

just like how you cant have independent journalism when they have no income

rayiner • today at 12:33 AM

> Capitalism has never been particularly kind to smart people who give a shit

"Capitalism" is, at best, orthogonal to this. When we came to the U.S. in the late 1980s, California was the world model for a place run by "smart people who give a shit." It was also so capitalist that Reagan and Nixon won Los Angeles. Twice each.

What you're really yearning for is a society run by high-agency, conscientious, low-bullshit unemotional people. You can find these people in social democracies or in libertarian capitalist states. You need "common people" who are socialized to take direction from "smart people"--with all sharing common goals of competence, efficiency, and orderliness in preference to other values.

ajasmin • today at 12:24 AM

Giving a shit is never rewarded. Other than the bottom line, stakeholders tend to prioritize burn down charts, business objectives, theme cohesion etc. often at the expanse of things just plain working.

When I ask to change things, it's not because I'm dick. I just want us to build stuff that I'd be pleased to use myself. Simple, elegant, bug-free, fast, secure and stable.

I used to find the Lean and Agile movements enticing but their implementation in enterprise often boils down to doing the minimum demanded of the current task and shelving it until somebody complains.

mococa • today at 12:43 AM

Give a shit and get fired

m0llusk • today at 12:11 AM

> Capitalism has never been particularly kind to smart people who give a shit

VisiCalc and the start of the spreadsheet era went pretty well for many people.

stego-tech • today at 12:30 AM

I’d like to think I’m smart. I’m definitely smart enough to solo-run IT for a small enterprise or as part of a team for a big F50 company, judging from my resume. I also give a shit, to the point of literally hurting myself in the past because I gave too much of a shit relative to compensation, my time, and my health.

And that’s exactly why I don’t really give a shit anymore, at least not “above and beyond” like my dumbass self did in my 20s and 30s, wasting away time “proving myself” only to get thrown in the dumpster during outsourcing or layoffs or petty grievances from clients.

Nobody pays me enough to buy a decent home in a decent part of town; not the current job I love, nor the prior jobs at huge conglomerates and household tech names. I spend two to four hours commuting from suburbia every day because I don’t make enough to live closer, nor enough to buy a home where I currently live. Watching my youth be squandered at the altar of Capital for nought - no house, no spouse, no sense of community - the only shits I can afford to give are proportional to my compensation package and not one more.

It’s not that we need smart people who give a shit; it’s that we need leaders to actually pay these smart people to give a shit. If my current employer paid me enough to buy a domicile near a subway stop, I’d gladly donate excess shits (and fucks) to night and weekend work again, if only because I wouldn’t be wasting a full fourth of my day in traffic anymore - and could afford to build the roots and community and love life I want for myself.

dbg31415 • today at 12:26 AM

And yet... every work place treats people who give a shit like they are the enemy. Care about doing a job you can be proud of, or care about something other than what your boss tells you to do, and you're a pariah.

Smart people say, "Hey did you think about XYZ?" during the planning phase. That makes the plan stretch out to a realistic deadline. How dare they! Ha. Nobody likes that. And it's been this way for a while. Maybe it's always been this way?

* Remembering Roger Boisjoly: He Tried To Stop Shuttle Challenger Launch : The Two-Way : NPR // https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2012/02/06/146490064...

acedTrex • today at 12:10 AM

Giving a shit is decimated in this day and age, everyone just slops shit and breaks things.

➕ show 1 reply
bshaughn • today at 12:36 AM

The status quote of how to run a business has enabled this extreme corporate abstraction that has completely detached decision makers and the capital class from understanding all the details that we nerds care about. I think Boeing is one of the best examples of this. What used to be a legendary organization with an engineering first culture, that was able to make the 747, has turned into this MBA led shell of itself that is the poster child for late stage capitalism.

The business leaders only see things that they can fit into their spreadsheets (both literally, and figuratively representing the mental models they use for decision making).

The productivity and skills of individual engineers get washed out via some average. The blockers and nonsense that slow down your best teams disappear, and those good teams are measured to be average. Building things the right way does not increase revenue so therefore it is not worth doing. Off shore engineers are cheaper so its more profitable to use them.

Do this a few hundred times and you get to this insane point where the mental model of those incharge is so off base from reality that planes start falling out of the sky...

Even if you have a pocket of middle managers who do understand, and want to communicate that change upward, you are still in a terrible spot of telling your bosses everything they know and have done is a lie.

This problem is not limited to just MBAs vs Engineers. We nerds are guilty of it in other ways. I have worked in Data Science / Machine Learning / AI Engineering my whole career - which always has the fascinating problem of building what stakeholders think is magic and managing those expectations. What I have noticed, especially the last year, is people use the magic of AI to offload the hard parts of product design, figuring out ugly data, contradictory business rules, etc... this sort of thinking feels good, because it lets us believe the problem is easier than it really is. But at the end you are left with some AI slop product, or disappointing automation.

I'll never forget attending a project proposal by a fresh big 4 consultant hire at my current job, that promised to save $10M in costs. The plan was literally: 1. Get data on < problem > (which did not exist in a useable way) 2. < My name > builds a solution with claude 3. we save $10M a year

Its literally the underpants --> ?? --> Profit meme from southpark.

I see this issue getting worse and worse, because the decision makers are further and further detached from the details that keep our planes from falling out of the sky, or outlook crashing.

The real work gets done in the trenches, and the generals don't know what the mud smells like. The one upside in all this, those who are willing to get into the trenches have the tools to leave the generals behind.

🔗 View 5 more comments