logoalt Hacker News

asdff • today at 12:16 AM • 0 replies • view on HN

I'm not sure how much that line is even really serious vs just a sort of way to ensure the country were sufficiently armed against reconquest by the British, with a very weak central government and hardly any ability to levy actual armies. In this way they'd make use of emotional feelings of patriotism and mandate of the people to just have the farmers and small folk behave somewhat irrationally, paying for the state's military expenditure directly out of their own wages, vs some tax structure that might actually impact real property wealth of which many of the founding fathers had substantial holdings. Especially when the role of the military is really to protect property rights vs some general protection of the people (e.g. the british and american revolutionaries had no fight with the poor folk who would be tilling fields in either way, it was really all about tax rates on large property holdings and business functionally, sold as a moment of liberation to drum the small folk into risking their lives and livelihoods). I mean really, ask yourself if you really have representation over your taxation today, or if it is controlled more by forces where you and your opinions are an irrelevant factor.

When you think it two steps ahead it really just makes no sense. So people are supposedly allowed to rise up against tyrannical government, but then what about John Brown, or the civil war for that matter? By this logic, the existing US government is tyrannical if they are actually squaring up to fight a citizen who has determined it is time to take up arms against what they perceive as a tyrranical government. The act of the government actually being baited into playing ball on this turns it into a tyrannical government by definition: here it is shooting and killing other American citizens who hold a political grievance. To say nothing on the positions of the civil war but to see it for what it is: a political debate that has gone hot.

Then you have to wonder especially with the military after the civil war, with more reorganization away from the local militia model, how would the government have behaved towards a group of citizens who are stockpiling up arms? I'm not sure they would have allowed joe shmoe from down the block in 1920 to have a basement full of tommy guns and dynamite either.