logoalt Hacker News

api • today at 12:57 PM • 3 replies • view on HN

Having responses doesn’t mean anything. Are the responses valid and grounded in reality? Is there evidence for them?

A skilled debater can argue any arbitrary position convincingly.

I thought of a short LT;DR version of why I am not a Rationalist: they think arguments are evidence.


Replies

ben_w • today at 1:37 PM

> I thought of a short LT;DR version of why I am not a Rationalist: they think arguments are evidence.

You're thinking of a-priorists.

Rationalists do not (at least not willfully) think arguments are evidence.

➕ show 1 reply
card_zero • today at 1:26 PM

> why I am not a Rationalist: they think arguments are evidence

That means something, right? But it's an argument.

saagarjha • today at 1:10 PM

I mean, the post doesn’t have evidence of its arguments either. It’s hard to come up with evidence for something that does not exist