logoalt Hacker News

jeremyjh • today at 1:01 PM • 4 replies • view on HN

Human brains are the product of millions of years of evolution. You have to include that training data as well for it to be a fair comparison.


Replies

zarzavat • today at 1:36 PM

All that evolution compresses to a GB or so of DNA (yes I know it's more complicated than that).

Humans are a bad example because of the well known width restriction leading us to be born undeveloped.

But animals can be born with varying levels of fully or partially developed neural networks despite having minimal data transfer from the parents and no apparent training data available in the womb/egg.

Nature is able to squeeze a lot more efficiency than our current AI efforts.

➕ show 2 replies
ftchd • today at 1:42 PM

I would argue that's the actual "training" part, and your lived experience is the equivalent of fine tuning.

➕ show 1 reply
ben_w • today at 1:32 PM

Kinda, but unclear how much pre-training of our brains evolution did exactly, only that even if DNA was just about the brain (it isn't) it would still be a tiny pre-train.

soco • today at 1:17 PM

Fair point. Those millions years of training however are not really contained in the corpus of data we are currently using in training AI, also the hardware is quite different - and created by processes with huge and significant differences, so I don't even know what apples with what oranges I should compare...

➕ show 1 reply