The OP is right, but the shorts always lose because the market will always be wrong.
If I had a million bucks I'd spend it developing a trading algorithm that completely ignored company fundamentals and analyzed only Vibes.
Very crowded business, that
I'd much rather invest in market fundamentals as an individual. Many billions are poured into (and made on) vibe-based market predictions. It's much safer to go after smaller returns on well priced stocks than play predict the market irrationality against behemoths. After all, it worked for Buffet.