I find the "faster thinking dog can't play chess" argument to be weird and possibly wrong.
If my dog could play 1B chess matches in 5 minutes, I'm guessing it would be able to play chess at some reasonable level (assuming rewards, reinforcement, etc. which seems table stakes to this argument)
These machines are already doing that (and more)
I think their argument here is sound. You need a certain amount of mental capability to hold a certain amount of complexity in your head.
Your dog would need to play 1B chess matches in 5 minutes AND learning from it not just playing and probably loosing.
Your dog and you are also perfect example of this: You can talk, the dog can't. No dog on our planet can, most humans can. Emerging feature of brainsize