Wow, they really misuse "alignment" in the article! They give a decent definition, and then proceed to ignore it.
Alignment == "training an AI system to act in a manner that aligns with human interests"
...but then they talk about guardrails and permissions as part of alignment. I think this is their weakest argument
Well, all of the heavy lifting in that definition is in how you interpret and draw the lines around "human interests". And even in the most minimalist interpretations of human interests, you still need guardrails to prevent the AI from doing wildly dangerous things.
For example, say you ask "get me plane tickets to Athens as cheaply as possible". Without any guardrails, the AI might hack the airline to try to get you tickets, or it might extort someone else for tickets, or any number of other wild schemes that would still fulfill the goal you set out for it.
And say you actually explicitly ask it to get you tickets to Athens as cheaply as possible using any means necessary, legal or illegal - the AI might easily land you in jail or get the flight canceled, thus entirely failing to accomplish your goal.