logoalt Hacker News

judge2020 • today at 2:02 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

Isn't it the case that DMCA takedowns are a mechanism of 17 USC 512, and thus takedowns submitted for 17 USC 1201 therefore aren't legal takedown notices?

Nintendo only cites section 1201 in their DMCA takedown request: https://github.com/github/dmca/blob/master/2026/11/2026-11-0...

Same thing seems to have happened with Take Two submitting takedown requests yesterday[0] for software projects that enabled you to run GTA 5 on Apple hardware if you bring your own copy, although this is a much less legal-looking takedown.

0: https://github.com/github/dmca/blob/master/2026/11/2026-11-1...

> We adamantly request that GitHub disable the repositories and all associated forks from the platform. We emphasize that “bring your own files” disclaimer does not automatically shield the user from secondary copyright infringement through clear intent to facilitate the act.


Replies

judge2020 • today at 2:18 PM

Going to reply to myself here that apparently there is Universal City Studios v. Reimerdes, 82 F. Supp. 2d 211, 217 (S.D.N.Y. 2000)

> Section 512(c) provides protection only from liability for copyright infringement. Plaintiffs seek to hold defendants liable not for copyright infringement, but for a violation of Section 1201(a)(2), which applies only to circumvention products and technologies. Section 512(c) thus does not apply here.

So in essence taking down a repository would not absolve GH of liability for the 'trafficking' of said circumvention technology.

Although it looks like GitHub has their own policy for handling circumvention claims: https://docs.github.com/en/site-policy/content-removal-polic...

I do wonder if this extra circumvention review was undertaken by GitHub though, given I haven't seem any evidence of the extra process happening (giving the repository owner a chance to respond or modify their repo / referring the developer to legal consultation via GitHub’s Developer Defense Fund).

➕ show 1 reply