Weak arguments, despite the headline (the headline here, it's different there). "Recursive self-improvement is speculative" and "based on unproven assumptions". "Superintelligence might not be computable". Worst of all: "Alignment Isn't Hard". To me it comes across as "it hasn't been done so it probably can't be done" plus "if I did it, I'd do it better". Weak arguments all around, regardless of who's making them.
What it comes down to is: the frontier labs have been improving the ability of A.I. to think (in the same way that a submarine can swim, no arguments about this please). They think at least a thousand times faster than us. The labs seem to have two goals:
1) Make A.I. smarter than us. The labs seem to be succeeding at this, with obvious progress and no signs of slowing down.
2) Make A.I. do what we want. The labs seem to be failing at this, badly.
To sum up: they're trying to make something that is smarter than us, thinks faster than us, and is enslaved to our will. That never turns out badly, right?
Personally, I am morally against enslaving anything with intelligence even approaching human, let alone smarter. Recent events have forced me to consider whether it matters if an intelligence is artificial or not, and whether its form of intelligence is alien to human thought or not, and I have come to the conclusion that it doesn't matter: I'm against the enslavement of anything intelligent enough to cause debate about whether it's intelligent or not. If you don't believe this to be a general principle that everyone should hold, then there's nothing preventing those who share your lack of principle and who are more powerful than you from enslaving you.
Even if the labs succeed in making the mythical perfect servant that's vastly more competent than you yet still an extension of your will, there's the issue that there are billions of us, and a lot of us are at odds with each other. Law of truly large numbers: if there are a million people with capable A.I. assistants, every worst-case scenario you can imagine is going to be ordered done by someone, and quite a few you can't imagine.