I am wondering if calling it "intelligence" is naybe a category error that disguises the underlying mechanisms that produce seemingly intelligent output.
In my experience, basic LLMs without reasoning still tend to make very dumb mistakes (such as omitting or inserting a "not" or otherwise stating the opposite of the correct response). It seems that the combination of CoT (for fixing errors) and tool use (for grounding the inference process) play a major role in making LRMs work.
I see LRMs not so much as a move towards intelligence, but as employing a heuristic-guided search for a goal condition (essentially pathfinding in token or latent space). Granted, with a very, very powerful heuristic, but the approach still seems to exhibit the same problems as other naive search algorithms, such as getting stuck in local optima [1]. And the answer for this by the labs when pursuing e.g. research math problems seems to be to throw agent swarms at the problem, i.e. pretty much the same quick fix we use to mitigate similar issues in classical search algorithms.
See also the problem of models being very good in areas where they can build on a pre-existing theory, such as much of research mathematics, but can flail around [2] and just offer the obvious ideas in fields without one (as they lack a way to determine neighbor nodes for an effective search).
Obviously, like pretty much everybody, I have no idea where AI will be a year from now; a new breakthrough can render any existing argument irrelevant, and we've already had several of those in the past decade. But I don't currently see incremental improvements moving past existing limitations of how LRMs work.
[1] E.g. https://bespokelabs.ai/blog/how-models-explore-ideas
[2] E.g. https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/DALNiKBjMGMF8grme/arjun-pani...