logoalt Hacker News

em-bee • today at 4:05 PM • 4 replies • view on HN

there is a lot more to rebuilding communities besides technology.

the whole social aspect. caring for others. not being selfish. trust.

the problem is that lack/failure of those is the reason for society collapsing in the first place.

so rather than learning how to preserve my own food i am interested in learning how to build good will, collaboration and consensus, especially in a diverse society.


Replies

alwa • today at 4:25 PM

One phenomenon I’d not thought of until I encountered it, but that seems obvious in retrospect: in the immediate course of an exogenous shock (like natural disaster or war or large-scale social disruption), people tend to really come through for their neighbors [0].

The most reliable pattern seems to be a temporary burst of social cohesion. To the extent that durable negative social outcomes materialize, they tend to (1) roughly follow the contours of the same new material/social circumstances had they developed non-suddenly; and (2) take weeks and maybe months to overcome that initial swell of empathy.

In any case I agree that the human side is the important side—we owe a nod to communities like the Amish and religious orders who’ve done a lot of R&D into social cohesion technologies during blue skies!

[0] (e.g. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7115229/ and https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/028072709801600305 and many others in the genre)

➕ show 1 reply
throwup238 • today at 5:18 PM

Trade networks are far more important for rebuilding society than any of the above. Massive trade networks capable of moving goods thousands of miles.

The materials to run society don’t exist all in one place and except for the recyclable metals that are available in bulk in most urban environments and lumber mills which are relatively well distributed, people are going to start running out of basics really fast and society will never get off the ground.

The ones who have the best chance at survival are ironically the billion or so subsistence farmers in poverty who are largely excluded from the modern economy anyway.

220hertz • today at 4:31 PM

Absolutely. Abstracted it's epistemology. We've spent a lot of time thinking about how to think over the ages, and it's served us pretty well.

dayvid • today at 5:15 PM

Tight-knit religious groups will do really well in a catastrophic event. The trust is hard to duplicate outside of maybe the military or similar orgs. Even Mormons have prepping built into their lifestyle.