logoalt Hacker News

triceratops • today at 5:25 PM • 1 reply • view on HN

> You think that if you read a book about de-escalation

Well I'd be better off than if I didn't read the book. Learning social skills and negotiation in real life is way more important obviously.

> Do all your neighbors have enough food to survive?

My neighbors would have food because I would share and so would they. And then we'd work out something to find or grow more food. Maybe, if it's really dire, we'd form our own looting band. Either way fighting each other would be disastrous for all of us long-term. Maybe survive together or definitely die alone.

> After 5 days with no food your neighbors will kill you for whatever you have.

Is that what you'd do if you were that neighbor? If yes, I'm sorry to tell you that you aren't normal.

If they kill me, who's going to stand with them when unfriendly people from outside the neighborhood show up?

> Your argument is you will be safe because humans are tribal. That argument works all the time, so why aren't people safe all the time?

People mostly are safe. You can walk down the street with virtually zero fear of getting stabbed. Or I don't know, maybe you're just a naturally fearful person. I'm not.


Replies

ltbarcly3 • today at 9:13 PM

> Well I'd be better off than if I didn't read the book.

This does not logically follow.

Let's talk about heart surgery. If you had to do heart surgery you would almost certainly botch it and the person would die. If you read a book on it the person would still almost certainly die. Reading a book and incrementally increasing trivial knowledge of something complex, like negotiating with starving survivors of a global apocalypse, might not be something you can meaningfully improve your skills at from reading a book one time awhile ago.

> Is that what you'd do if you were that neighbor? If yes, I'm sorry to tell you that you aren't normal.

You are very naive. Read about every time this has happened in the past and how people behaved.

> If they kill me, who's going to stand with them

LOL, great speech for your screenplay.

> Or I don't know, maybe you're just a naturally fearful person.

I think you have lived a very comfortable life.

➕ show 1 reply