logoalt Hacker News

bluegatty • today at 7:07 PM • 5 replies • view on HN

AI is not even close to replacing SWEs.

AI can write syntactically perfect code but barely has a sense of architecture.

It needs tons of 'guide wires' to keep it from going off track.

Unless you're building basic SaaS, it's still a 'research and coding assistant'.

AI has never produced non-messy architecture that I did not have to go in, re-think and guide a re-write.


Replies

IronWolve • today at 7:17 PM

This is spot on, AI can code, but it doesnt have the experience in the real world, so many things are designed differently from spec.

SWE's have to guide the AI, look at all those AI PR's, many of them make very bad assumptions.

elxr • today at 8:11 PM

> AI can write syntactically perfect code but barely has a sense of architecture.

Second point should be obvious to anyone actually building something even slightly new/complex.

taurath • today at 8:08 PM

The hype is so far outside of what it can actually do in many businesses. People running around saying AI has "solved" coding but code has never been the difficult part of the job, and AI hasn't solved the bringing together of context, intention, history, and various people's understanding. You can go far in tightly controlled situations, but it can also accelerate your technical debt until you become utterly dependent on tradeoffs that AI made for you. Eventually you can't do anything safely.

So many executives have turned all the safeties off and given over control of their business to a probabilistic system and ignored every engineer who said its dangerous and risky. The engineers will be the ones held accountable though, because since AI is "so effective" it must be operator error

markus_zhang • today at 8:37 PM

Counter point: you don’t need architecture big things everyday, at least I don’t and everyone in my role (data engineering) knows that we don’t do that often.

Ofc unless you call some data modelling “architect” but I’m sure AI is fine for that. Guess how I know.

throw-the-towel • today at 8:16 PM

You're technically correct which is the best kind of correct -- but is your experience with these matters still as valuable as it used to be? How are you going to prove to management that it is? And who's to say that eventually AI won't be able to brute force its way into maintaining its slop? (Of course we can't be sure it will either, but you get my point.)

➕ show 1 reply