logoalt Hacker News

xhevahir • today at 7:39 PM • 4 replies • view on HN

"Midwest" has long been a pet peeve of mine; I don't understand what states like Michigan and South Dakota are supposed to have in common. It's like a more neutral way of saying "flyover country." That's a nice-looking website, but i would divide this news at least into a Great Plains category and a Great Lakes.


Replies

slim • today at 7:48 PM

Why do you want division ? Unity is much better

jerf • today at 7:57 PM

Also, Midwest of what, exactly? Most of the "midwest" is in the eastern half of the United States, if not all of it depending on your definition. It's west of the east coast, sure... but that doesn't exactly nail it down now, does it? Not exactly a surprise, that? The "mid" makes some sense on its own but I've never understood what the "west" was doing in there, nor particularly how they combine. The history of the term makes sense, in terms of how it was used in the 18th century, but its persistence into the 21st is a bit odd. You can't just say "inertia", many many other similar names from the 18th century are long gone. But somehow this particular one sticks around even though it is facially false.

It doesn't "bother" me, but it does make me intellectual wonder what it is about the term that has kept it around when so many other seemingly more suitable ones have been dead for hundreds of years.

thesuitonym • today at 8:27 PM

Indeed, I always thought that the midwest should be Minnesota, the Dakotas, Iowa, Nebraska, and Kansas. Maybe Illinois and Missouri can come too, sometimes. The Great Lakes states should be called...well the Great Lakes region! Or perhaps, because they're in the middle portion of the eastern United States, we could call it the middle east.

roosterIllusi0n • today at 7:56 PM

SD is west. The midwest coast centers around the midwestern great lakes.