logoalt Hacker News

idle_zealot • yesterday at 11:34 PM • 4 replies • view on HN

That "sole determinant" bit is concerning. So it's established now that when the AI tells you that there's probable cause you should then ask it to parallel-construct another source and present that when questioned. I guess this at least catches cops too stupid or lazy to integrate that step?


Replies

dcrazy • today at 3:56 AM

It’s not “parallel construction” to investigate an AI-generated hypothesis in good faith. If the officer in this case had been acting in good faith, he would have at least tried to find some proof of his completely unsubstantiated theory that the Facebook profile was an alias for the plaintiff.

trothamel • yesterday at 11:53 PM

As far as I can tell, the system seems to be a fancier version of google image search. I think it's reasonable for a detective to toss an image into google image search, and look at the top matches. What he shouldn't be doing is avoiding verifying that the images actually match.

Assuming the underlying crime should be a crime (and check fraud seems like it should be a crime), we do want the police to catch the actual criminals.

It strikes me that AI is a red herring here - this is about image matching.

vibebingo • yesterday at 11:46 PM

This is a core AI human interaction problem in a nutshell. It genetates synthetic reasoning and then a human is either convinced by it or too busy or lazy or corrupt to think for themselves and presents it as their own thinking.

nextaccountic • today at 1:43 AM

This should be viewed as processual fraud