logoalt Hacker News

eterm • today at 12:15 AM • 8 replies • view on HN

> "Based on our investigation so far, we believe the attackers accessed certain marketing data held by those vendors, which may include some customer names and email addresses,"

A big question that I think will increasingly be asked as this sort of thing becomes more widespread: Did these customers really give informed consent to their data being passed to these "third party vendors" that are getting breached?

Even with regulation such as CCPA and GDPR in Europe, a lack of meaningful consequences has meant a complete abdication of treating customer data as a liability.

Maybe companies will be more careful with handing out data to third parties if they can no-longer trust those third parties to keep the data secure and it becomes a reputational risk.

Of course that remains to be seen, this one will likely fade into noise and have little to no effect long term, but I am hopeful that meaningful attitude change to data will happen as an effect of the continuing vuln-pocalypse.

An alternate technical point of view: there's also an argument for the need for a better way than emails or SMS for being contacted by companies with which we do business. If a contact grant was handled in a more privacy-preserving manner, then you could authorise companies to send you messages without giving up a form of identification, and this authority could then even be also appropriately delegated in a more secure way.


Replies

chneu • today at 12:19 AM

>Maybe companies will be more careful with handing out data to third parties if they can no-longer trust those third parties to keep the data secure and it becomes a reputational risk.

They don't care about reputation. Like 3/4 of people have the mentality their data is already out there. They don't care.

The only thing these companies care about is $$$ because they're too big to care. They are engrained in the US system.

➕ show 1 reply
oliyoung • today at 12:26 AM

> A big question that I think will increasingly be asked as this sort of thing becomes more widespread: Did these customers really give informed consent to their data being passed to these "third party vendors" that are getting breached?

As a Domain Arch in consumer retail in Australia, those laws are getting SIGNIFICANTLY restricted now, a lot of the implied consent that existed is now being questioned, even across business units of a single company, and that's the exact question that's being asked.

Our legal department is tightening PI and consent considerably, and its going to leave our marketing teams without a lot of the tools and capabilities they've been going to for a long time.

Can't say I disagree with any of it either

makeitdouble • today at 1:19 AM

> informed consent

In theory that should be the right framing, in practice having the information means nothing if there is no reasonable action you can take from there.

In the case of Visa and MasterCard, Amex or JCB or Diners' terms aren't better or more competitive, your only real option is to give up on credit cards altogether.

A lot of otherwise sensible concepts have little weight when you have a cartel or straight duopolies/monopolies.

➕ show 1 reply
browningstreet • today at 1:45 AM

Having worked at one of these companies, banks especially take this kind of data privacy and regulation stuff seriously. It’s all in the terms of service you blindly click through, but they deal with data provenance and chain of custody seriously.

The big problem is the number of external marketing SaaS vendors all these financial service marketing orgs tend to use. It’s too big a surface area for true security assurance.

preg_match • today at 12:55 AM

> Maybe companies will be more careful with handing out data to third parties if they can no-longer trust those third parties to keep the data secure and it becomes a reputational risk.

No no no, you've got it backwards. The reputational risk is not giving data to third parties. The more third-parties you involve, and the more you offload, the lower the reputational risk.

The purpose of many companies is not their product or their service, it's accountability laundering. If you make it someone else's problem, you don't have to care. If JP Morgan had the leak instead, it would be much worse for them. Much, much worse. Now, a sane person would say "well then JP Morgan why don't you just design your systems to prevent a leak?" but that's not how risk-averse leaders see it.

They see it as "the leak is inevitable". Now, do you want to leak the data, or do you want someone else to leak the data? There's a secret third option which is "don't collect the data" but nobody actually considers that. Realistically, you just outsource some operation to however the hell you like. Then, when things go wrong, you wipe your hands, maybe make a PR release about how you "trusted them", and then move on to dump your operations into another third party. Fingers crossed this one doesn't leak!

matt3210 • today at 1:37 AM

do they need consent? Legally speaking I mean are they required to get consent in the usa? I would hope yes but I don;t know

ethnrob • today at 12:31 AM

Are we already too far gone? In theory companies are meant to manage subprocessors of the entire chain. In practice, that amounts to hundreds of them.

jen20 • today at 12:59 AM

Personally the only thing I’ll find acceptable is personal criminal and financial liability for executives in the case of data breaches - SOX style.