logoalt Hacker News

js4ever • today at 12:27 AM • 13 replies • view on HN

Is it just me or all Google models are terribly bad? They all seems benchmaxed to hell and producing total crap compared to Claude or openai models from my own experience (mostly coding)


Replies

hadlock • today at 12:34 AM

After hearing some good things from my tokenmaxxing buddies (or whatever you want to call them, AI enthusiasts), I got a $20/mo sub to try out Neon and it's just breezed through some hardware graphics bring-up problems I've been struggling with on Sol/Astra and Fable. I'm gonna drop my $200 OpenAI sub this coming month in favor of Google's $200 plan just for more Neon tokens.

➕ show 1 reply
danpalmer • today at 12:48 AM

It's just you. Since Argon, the Gemini models have been producing good results for me side-by-side with Opus/Fable models on the same prompts. Not always winning, but increasingly so with Carbon/Neon.

SwellJoe • today at 12:31 AM

I think it's just you. Carbon is excellent but extremely slow. If Neon is better than or equal to Carbon while also being a lot faster, that'd be a great model. I haven't tried Neon, yet, but they seem to have understood the assignment with the latest round of models.

asadm • today at 12:43 AM

this week I ran out of codex astra quota and switched to antigravity, boy is Gemini Carbon amazing model! It actually helped achieve a breakthrough I was stuck on for weeks with Astra.

etoxin • today at 12:49 AM

I'm using AI heavily at work. I'm switching all my opus 5.5 sub-agents to neon. I'm quite impressed.

Yahivin • today at 12:37 AM

With Neon Gemini is good now.

➕ show 1 reply
mjburgess • today at 12:30 AM

And tokens/task is very high. They don't seem to have figured out making the models usable in a typical interactive workflow, ie., they're in a Opus-4.7 era.

Very high hallucination rates too.

➕ show 1 reply
elxr • today at 1:24 AM

Argon was bad yeah.

All the 3.x flash models were actually dumb compared to everything else it competed with.

Neon seems promising.

copperx • today at 12:30 AM

Are you saying Neon is just as bad?

horacemorace • today at 12:59 AM

Carbon changed my mind.

_s_a_m_ • today at 2:07 AM

i already went through the whole quota for Neon, it is on high to xhigh almost as good as Opus 5.5, almost equal. Most people who dont do deep learning model rewrites and other math stuff and statistics like me wont probably even notice a difference.

CamperBob2 • today at 1:11 AM

Is it just me or all Google models are terribly bad?

Not this one.

azan_ • today at 12:32 AM

Yes. Every Google model so far has been disappointment. And their biggest moat, the integration into other google products has been laughable. Today I've asked gemini in gmail to download all attachments from one e-mail address and it turned out it's unable to do it. It's unbelievable how incompetent they are, Google has such a massive edge over OAI and Anthropic and it's still losing.

➕ show 2 replies