logoalt Hacker News

hazmazlaz • today at 4:23 AM • 0 replies • view on HN

I just had a pretty negative experience with Neon 4.

(Antigravity GUI client on MacOS, Extra effort level)

I asked agy to find bugs and performance optimization opportunities in some code implementing a OpenGL to Metal graphics bridge.

1. introduced four (4) P1 regressions, essentially breaking everything in a very obvious way

2. wrote no new tests for the code it wrote

3. its code failed five existing tests

4. at least half of the bugs it diagnosed were wrong, e.g. false finding entirely - not a bug, correctly working code

5. correctly diagnosed some previously undiscovered bugs, but either wrote partial or incorrect fixes for most of them

6. correctly diagnosed and wrote correct fixes for only 2 out of a total of like 10 "findings"

Disappointed, this sounded like it would be a big win for Google and put them back at the head of the pack.