> Assignment documents that start with "you are strongly encouraged to explore the use of AI" which quickly turns into the clear understanding that you aren't just encouraged but expected to use it. That you're disadvantaged by not using it. The hardest class of my degree was spent in a brick-walled windowless computer lab prompting an AI for eight hours a day.
College education for software developers has never been particularly good, but it seems like now they've actually just given up.
Do we accept this in any other field? Does your math professor teach you to solve integrals by asking WolframAlpha?
You can give people access to a library. And some will use it to their advantage but most will just not be able to do anything with the information they have at their fingerprints. That's been true for as long as we've had libraries, books, and all the rest. Giving people AIs isn't really any different.
Some people have a natural curiosity and drive to explore and will go through great lengths to figure something out with whatever tools there are. Universities are where these people hone their skills. At least on paper. Some universities aren't actually that good at that and are glorified learning factories that prioritize churning out skilled workers rather than good researchers.
> College education for software developers has never been particularly good
Several people that laid the foundations of computer science are still alive (e.g. Donald Knuth). This field is very young. When I studied computer science, the department was staffed by people that mostly had mathematics degrees. Because there was no computer science department until about ten years before I started in 1994. How do you think math education worked a few centuries ago? LLMs literally went from being completely and utterly a science fiction topic for most of my life to science fact over the course of my professional career. I'm only 52. I still have a few decades left in my career.
There is no university program that can prepare you for that amount of rapid change. Other than to give you the mental tools to learn and adapt.
That’s pretty batshit crazy. I finished my CS Master’s this summer (after getting laid off, after several years in working life), and mostly we were told to use AI responsibly and that undisclosed inclusion of AI prose or code may be considered plagiarization/cheating, as it clearly ought to be in an academic setting.
One course expressly forbade using AI to solve or write code for any specific exercise problems; it included a group project and you can’t imagine how nonplussed I was when I saw that another member’s contribution was obviously almost directly from an LLM…
I think responsible use of LLMs in the academia should involve citing at least the entire prompting logs, if not all the agents’ internal logs as well.
My university president is pushing for AI in everything.
Personally, I a have come to the conclusion that making business apps is no longer a STEM education required profession. If your goal is to make web apps then you will be a prompter, and the the College of Business (or College of Vibecoding, or whatever) is where the education will be. And it will be finding information for the clanker. No math, no calculus, no programming.
Computer Science will still exist. It will be 95% smaller. And the 'software engineering stuff' like requirements and actual testing and design will be explained in a couple of slides in a single lecture.
In academia, almost all AI use is wrong. Thinking, understanding, expressing yourself. The AI does not help those skills at all. The work product you create has no value; rather it is what you had to learn to make the work product. (focus on undergraduate work here, there is some nuance in research).
We have to stop focusing on the work product, and move to the journey.
These days you just ask chat GPT. It gives you the working steps. If you have a particularly large budget you can even ask it to write the risch algorithm for you.
Roles change and inevitably software development for most is likely to move further and further away from computer science.
If there were 100 different ways to solve it, and 1000 languages to do it in, sure.
> College education for software developers has never been particularly good
I'm really happy with the education I received in uni (mid 2010s). As part of my bachelor's I had to wrestle threads in C and C++, got O(N^2) code rejected for O(N*logN) problems, I got to write client-server apps in Java, do (graded) exercises in Prolog and Common Lisp, build web apps in PHP, configure Cisco IOS devices from scratch, draw diagrams of CMOS gates on paper, write Bash scripts handling newlines in file names, program robots in Python, write Lambda calculus expressions by hand, write XSD schemas, recognize a context-sensitive grammar, ...
I benefit from that a lot and I regularly notice that I'm using something or building upon something I remember from uni. It always seems weird to me when people say that you don't need any of that on the actual job. So what else do you need? Clicking through GitLab or Jira, remembering the 3 git commands you usually use and being comfortable in a particular IDE? You can learn all that on a rainy weekend, I'd be seriously pissed off if I'd spent my time in uni doing that.